First of all, before giving you guys all of the theories, I would like to thank everyone who's been supporting me from the beginning, my family, friends and my friends I met on Wattpad, who've been reading, voting and commenting. I really can't believe I reached that far in the story, I definitely wouldn't have done it without all of the support, so thanks for making me so proud of myself and for all of those amazing comments and reviews you've been giving me that always encouraged me to keep writing and work as hard as I can to produce the chapters in their best ways I could.

Anyways, the party is now all about you guys so in order to honor you, I wanted to share all of your theories and actually someone (NOT MENTIONING WHO) guessed exactly who Ben and Lucy are ;) But first things first, shoutouts to you for being the best readers ever naddaa_ PandaLover_02_ Athina4Ever NMAboElhoda JerryJucky97 JaneyJordan Featherfur2 stormkitty529 MidnightBloomer daddyskittyval Lika97hika heidiismail98 NerdyAlvio salmaMabbas Moe9423 poetrimoore erikakekikoku22

Let's start with the theories I received before you knowing about Ben and Lucy :)

"Jessica is still alive"

"Jessica had a twin called Sierra.'

"David shouldn't be trusted"

"Telling David wasn't a good idea"

"James not wanting to tell the police about the notebook makes him suspicious"

"Maria shouldn't trust James"

"Andrew us sketchy"

"James gives a killer vibe"

"James is suspicious"

"Conspiracy"

"Maybe they all did it together"

"David and James on it together."

"I really don't trust Wesley or his wife, I think that she doesn't have a mental break down, she is just pretending so that the police wouldn't ask her many questions that she and her husband can't answer, and also even if Wesley didn't kill her, he was the one who drugged her, or maybe he know who killed her and he is just helping."

"Keira must have been yelling at Sierra warning her that her husband was about to kill her and since he did, he had threatened her so she doesn't tell anyone. He has the sedative as a warning for her if she gets close to telling he puts her to sleep and just calls it a mental illness. He probably told her in the first place because he wanted her to be the one turning off the lights but she refused so he got someone else. "

"Who walks around with sedatives"

"suspicious for me..being a nurse you have to go to college to be one, and when you're in college they have subjects where they dissect animals, which has a lot of blood, plus patients come and go with blood even if you're just doing the routine check up/s..she couldn't possibly work as a nurse without seeing blood..I think it's an alibi..maybe she's the killer or she's protecting someone"

"Ricky and Nina are involved, but not the murderers"

"Eve is gonna get killed"

" I love the intrigue surrounding the boyfriends and the former nurse who faints around blood"

"The boyfriend has a lot to gain"

"The guests all teamed up to kill her."

"It was a suicide"

"I don't think Andrew did it"

"David cheated on Maria and Got Jessica pregnant AND wanted to get rid of her And Asked Eve to help him claiming that Jessica is Pregnant with Andrew's Child and Maria just crossed paths with Jessica in such a time?!"

"David sent that guy at the hotel to kill her"

"Liam is not to be trusted"

"James till now is not suspicious to me because his reactions with Maria is quite Logical, she can't be like that irresponsible getting involved with his work , she could mess things up or at least she could get hurt..."

"I think Wesley's Wife Keira is gonna get killed because she seems to know a lot and maybe the young maid , I also think that there is more than one guilty as may be more than one arranged this murder, they all know more than they said and this must be for a reason."

"I still think that James is somehow involved, Don't u think its odd how Only him knew where the notebook was and in the same night Maria told him about where she hid it, in the hotel room, Someone tries to kill her, don't u think its somehow, Idk, suspicious?"

"James is involved, what if Jessica/Sierra was somehow involved with the case that got his wife and daughter killed and he just wanted revenge?? I mean, he was the ONLY one that knew about that notebook being in her hotel room so he sent someone out there to kill her? What if the nurse is gonna get killed later because James went and told Wesley everything the nurse told him? What if the baby is James'? Or maybe they'd kill Keira"

"I don't trust doctor Wes"

"Liam is danger"

"I think the murderer who will get revealed is gonna be one of the other girls, not Eve or Keira."

"Jackson and Eve did it cause Eve was jealous of Sierra. They knew that Sierra was pregnant with Andrew's child so they killed her. Jackson will take the money and Eve will take Andrew back."

"I still think that Ben and Lucy are Somehow Andrew and maybe Eve??? I don't know, maybe he never wanted Sierra to get pregnant, maybe he wanted to drag her to tell him about heroine, or her boss?? IDK it's complicated But I think one of the suspects saw this incident at the train station and know what exactly happened and will tell the truth to get Maria out and I think more people are gonna die, probably the maid, if Eve is not involved she maybe will die because she knows thing on Andrew?? Idk but I have a bad feeling that Detective James will be affected in a bad way or get an injury, I hope not."

"I'm more worried about Jessica, if that's her real name, seems like a lot of stuff happens to her before she died"

"I knew it was more than one murderer"

"I don't even trust anyone anymore, the mastermind has an unknown identity, so it could be her boyfriend, the detective or the chief- is he the chief of police? I suspect the father more than the son. I think the son can be just at the wrong place at the wrong time or he's really in on it.."

"So Andrew, Nina, Ricky are no longer my suspect, Lily was dead. So there...Is Ethan the He? Why did Jessica have so many names? Why do I think the case larger than it seems?"

"Ethan. David. I don't trust them"

"I think David or James it the HE"

"I don't trust Ethan"

"Oh my! There is so much going on....I still don't totally trust anyone, including David. I'd love to say that Andrew is guilty, but because he's so obvious, as pointed out, it's probably not him. All I know is there are a few very rotten people and hopefully Maria escapes unscathed!"

"Maybe there is a character who looks like Maria will get killed by mistake, and if James or Ethan or even David is ben or the HE, they will trap and trick someone to try and kill maria so they get all the suspicion off themselves."

"I feel Detective James is gonna get killed and it's not a happy ending."

"And, I really think that Keira is Lucy and Wesley is afraid of her so promised not to tell, and also if he gets killed Keira would look so guilty"

"I think Wesley might be "He" because he is the one closest to drugs since he is a doctor and really who carries sedatives in their pocket,I mean probably no one. I think that Ricky and Nina are Ben and Lucy,it does make sense if Ricky did frame Nina because he's closest to her and he was the only one interacted closely with her besides Lily and Andrew before the killing. I feel like Ricky or Lily put the immune suppressive drugs in the hair creams and I feel like they got it from Wesley. But he stole the evidence from Sia room,so he and Eve or Lily or Ricky or Nina won't be in trouble. I feel like Eve was the cover up,so they would not get framed but it back fired on them. It is suspicious that Andrew was following Sia before she died and that he knew all of her alias's but I was thinking maybe he is "He" and Wesley is Ben and Kiera is Lucy. I can't figure out Liam or Miranda motives but Jackson it would make sense why he would do it."

"If Ricky really did love Nina, why would he frame her? I understand if he might want to black mail Sia because she knew about them but I don't think kill her"

I think that's all for the theories and I apologize if I missed any. :)

Let's get to the more important part, the guesses about Ben, Lucy, and the HE. ;)

I got a lot of comment saying that either James, Ethan, Liam or David is involved or maybe even more than one.

Ben and Lucy could be: Ricky and Nina, Keira and Jackson, Keira and Wesley, Miranda and Jackson, Eve and Jackson, Miranda and Andrew, Andrew and Eve.

So that's everything, hope you enjoy the theories and thanks for sharing them.