Spencer poured coffee into two mugs on the kitchen counter.

"Someone needs a caffeine fix this morning" Melissa teased as she came down the stairs.

"One of them is for Toby" Spencer said rolling her eyes.

"Ah yes, you two lovebirds are the talk of the town." Melissa smirked at her little sister. Spencer still couldn't believe how the town had lost their minds when she and toby began waltzing around town together to fit the narrative they had fed her parents. Spencer had begun to regret the idea.

"Is it real?" Melissa whispered even though their parents had gone to NYC for a long weekend, "I thought it was a play to get mom and dad off your back?"

"It was at first, I don't know" Spencer huffed. She was very confused. Toby had said he wanted them to try dating while they were pretending anyway but he hadn't made a move. After three rejections, she'd be damned to throw herself at him again.

"Hmm" Melissa said pouring herself some coffee in a tumbler and leaving the house. Spencer didn't have time to think about how she was feeling because Toby was walking in the back door.

"Hey Spence?" Toby said sitting at the counter in front of the coffee mug he always used. "What do you want to do tonight?"

Spencer didn't have an answer. She was tired of the two of them parading around town. She missed the way things used to be when they just did things they liked doing without being worried about being seen.

"Earth to Spencer" toby said pulling her out of the fog. "Is something wrong?"

"Can we maybe just rent some bullshit movies tonight like we used to?"

"Yeah of course" toby said rubbing her back. The feel of Toby's hand on her brought her back to the innocent fake make out that had turned super real a few weeks ago. She wanted him badly and who knew maybe this movie night would give them the opportunity to explore things again.

"We better get going" Spencer said pointing to Toby's half full cup before downing the rest of her own.

"Yeah" he replied finishing his coffee and taking her hand walking out to the car.

"Toby my parents aren't here" she said motioning to her hand. He pulled her close whispering.

"I like holding it"

A thrill went up Spencer's back making her legs feel like jello. She fought the urge to tell him they should skip school and go up to her room, reminding herself he'd already turned her down. Twice.

When they arrived at school, their friends were in the courtyard looking quite conspiratorial.

"What's going on?" Spencer said as they approached. Toby's arm wrapped around the small of her back comfortably.

"One of my Hollis friends just started working as a doorman at Nirvana in Philly and can totally get us in." Ali said in a hushed whisper.

"Caleb and Ezra are going to drive." Hanna announced.

"Ezra and I will pick you two up at 8" Aria said.
Spencer winced internally not feeling up to a big night out. She was looking forward to her and Toby stuffing themselves with pizza and junk food and passing out on the couch like they used to.

"Spencer and I have plans" Toby said before Spencer could think up an excuse.

Ali glared up at the couple.

"This is the hottest club in the city, fucking celebrities could be there."

"What could you possibly be doing that's more fun?" Ali demanded.

"It's a secret, big surprise date for Spencer, already booked, no refunds, catch you next time Ali."

Spencer smiled and nodded in agreement corroborating Toby's story.

"I can't with you two right now" Ali said shooing them away.

After they rounded the corner, Spencer raised an eyebrow at Toby "big surprise date night?"

"I panicked" he shrugged, "I know you wanted to stay in tonight."

"Thanks" Spencer said beaming up at him. She wasn't sure but she thought she might've seen him blush.

Spencer reveled in the thought of her and Toby spending a simple night watching movies the way it used to be before things were so complicated.

"What movies do you want to stream?" Spencer asked as they returned to her house after school.

"Whatever you want" Toby said with a shrug as he plopped his bag on the floor and sat on the couch.

"Coffee?" Spencer asked from the kitchen already making a pot.

"You know it" Toby said from the living room.

Spencer barely noticed when Toby got up from the couch walking over to the kitchen counter. Spencer was arranging a tray of bagel bites when she paused noticing Toby was standing behind her. She took in a sharp breath unsure what was about to happen.

Toby brushed her hair off to the side leaving wet mouth kiss on her neck.

"Toby what are you doing?" Spencer asked as Toby wrapped an arm around her hips beginning to finger her.

"I'm tired of pretending I don't want you." he growled in her ear.

"Tired of having to jerkoff or take a cold shower every night."

"Say it again" Spencer whined as Toby brought her closer.

"I want you" Toby said rubbing her clit harder in an attempt to get her to come, "my dicks so hard for you."

"Don't make me beg for it" Spencer mewled as Toby's fingers brought her painfully close.

"No baby," Toby said stopping his hand before she could cum "I'm not gonna make you beg. I'm gonna give you what you want tonight."

Toby grabbed Spencer's hand pulling it to the bulge in his pants.

"Feel how hard you make me?"

Spencer nodded rubbing the bulge until Toby cursed under his breath.

"Take me upstairs Spencer" Toby said pulling away from her, "we'll only do this if it's what you want."

"We're not pretending anymore are we?" Spencer asked in a whisper.

"I was never pretending" Toby said with a shrug.

Spencer was sure if Toby had been touching her those words would've made her cum.

"Upstairs" she panted grabbing Toby's hand and leading him upstairs.

Once in the privacy of her room Spencer wrapped her arms around Toby's neck kissing him intently, letting a moan out when Toby roughly grabbed her breasts. She could feel him pushing against his jeans begging to be let out.

Toby pulled away cupping Spencer's face in his hands as he looked down at her.

"This is going to change everything" Toby said looking rather serious.

"Promise?"

"Oh Spencer" Toby breathed as he melted into her. He began trailing kisses down her neck making a slow trail downward getting onto his knees, "get on the bed"

Spencer laid on the bed obediently, surprised when Toby yanked her sweat pants and panties off. Toby positioned himself so his mouth was over Spencer's center. He began rubbing her clit with a finger looking for the most sensitive spot testing out angles and pressure.

"How's that feel baby" Toby said huskily.

"It feels good" she panted as Toby rubbed faster, adding pressure, "so good"

Toby leaned down licking her sensitive clit slowly at first before gradually speeding up. Soon Spencer's legs were shaking on the brink of orgasm.

"Don't stop, oh yes yes yes fuck me toby, fuck me, fuck!" Spencer yelled thankful they were in the house alone. Toby let out an evil chuckle as he went back to licking her clit grabbing her hands so she couldn't push him away. Spencer writhed on the bed screaming and cursing as Toby made her cum hard again. Toby stood pulling her loose tshirt over her head. He yanked his own shirt off before undoing his pants and pushing them down with his boxers and stepping out of them.

Toby climbed over Spencer kissing her passionately as he pushed into her. Despite her wetness Toby could tell Spencer needed to get accustomed to him inside her. As she did Toby began to move. When Spencer began moaning and circling her hips Toby took it as an invitation to speed up.

"Toby!" Spencer panted as he continued to thrust harder.

"You wanna cum?" Toby said slowing himself knowing she was close.

"Yes" she cried.

"You're mine, you belong to me!" Toby ordered.

Spencer nodded.

"I want to hear you say it"

"I'm yours, I belong to you" Spencer said as Toby began pumping into her steadily.

"Should I make you cum?" Toby asked in a teasing voice.

"Make me cum, please make me fucking cum!"

"Oh Spencer" Toby growled as he gripped her hips, drilling into her. He captured her mouth with his as she whined for the impending release. He slammed into her burying himself as she screamed from orgasm. Spencer wrapped her legs around his hips.

"Cum inside me" she moaned her spasming walls  and words of encouragement enough to make him explode.

"I love you Spencer, I love you so fucking much."

"I love you too" Spencer panted as toby finally pulled out of her.

They laid there a minute before Toby turned on his side to look at her naked spent body.

"What are you thinking about?" He asked propping his head up with his arm.

"I didn't know it could be like that?"

"Like what?"

"Rough. Passionate. Pleasurable." She said rubbing her center remembering the pleasure.

"You didn't know it was pleasurable" toby asked with a chuckle before realizing what she was saying, "it wasn't like that with Alex? You don't have to tell me, if you don't want."

"It was kinda nice after the losing my virginity part." Spencer mumbled, "it wasn't anything close to this."

"You want to do it again?" He asked kissing her and rubbing her center.

"In a little while. Sleepy. Hold me." Spencer said turning away from him, pulling his arm around her.

"Always"

And within minutes they were both asleep.

***
The next time Spencer awoke she could see daylight breaking out her window. She stretched before rolling over looking for Toby. At first she thought maybe she'd dreamt last night but if it had been a dream she wouldn't still be naked in bed and she didn't wouldn't have a light ache in pelvis from a night of passionate love making.

"Toby?" she called before hearing water in the bathroom. He emerged from her bathroom still naked like she was, his dick semi erect already.

"Yeah baby?" He said absentmindedly stroking himself.

"For a minute, I thought maybe you left"

"I wouldn't do that to you" he said kissing her forehead, his stroking becoming more purposeful. Spencer kneeled on the floor beckoning him towards her. She pulled him to her taking in his length.

"Do you know how many fantasies you're fulfilling right now" Toby panted grabbing a fist full of her hair as Spencer went from pushing his length as far back as it would go to sucking his tip. "Oh god I want to cum in your mouth."

Spencer kept going and Toby was sure he wasn't going to be able to hold it much longer.

"Can I baby? Can I please cum in your mouth?"

Spencer pulled back so only the tip was in her mouth as she nodded. She began sucking his tip hard and Toby cursed at the feel.

"Fuck, I'm gonna cum. Rub my balls"

The combination of Spencer's sucking and rubbing his balls was enough to make him cum.

After years of secretly having a crush on her, the sight of Spencer sucking his cum out of his throbbing cock, he was sure he'd never thought she was more beautiful.

"Get on the bed" he ordered dark lust in his eyes.

Spencer laid down on the bed, nervous for what he had in store. When he laid down he beckoned her with a finger.

"Come here" he said teasingly. Spencer went to kiss him as she straddled his hips.

Toby pulled away shaking his head.

"Sit on my face"

Spencer gave him a perplexed look.

"Bring my pussy to me" he said pulling her up his body, "I'm gonna fuck your brains"

Toby gave her a small lick to start before pulling away.

"Wet already, huh? Sucking my dick really made you horny"

Spencer nodded shyly as Toby went back to licking her.

Spencer whimpered as Toby tongued her clit. He grabbed her hands putting them in his hair and wrapped his arms around her hips to hold her in place when he made her cum.

"Toby" Spencer breathed as he licked her. He went slow at first not wanting her to get too riled up too quickly. As he started moving his tongue over her faster she began moving her hips.

"Feels so good" Spencer panted giving his hair a squeeze and pushing his mouth in farther. Toby moaned send a wave of pleasure through her. He continued licking her changing speeds so Spencer didn't cum easily.

"Please" Spencer whined after rounds of orgasm denial. Toby delved his tongue in her wet pussy before letting his tongue assault her clit. Toby enjoyed the feel of Spencer's excitement as he got her close. When she tried to pull away he held her in place.

"No no baby girl you're gonna take it"

Before Spencer could respond, Toby was sucking on her clit and then flicking it with his tongue and back. Spencer whimpered, screamed and cursed as Toby held her in place making her cum.

"Fuck!" Spencer cried as Toby delivered orgasm number 2. Spencer dug her nails into his shoulder as he kept pleasuring her. When he finally decided he was done torturing Spencer he threw her down on the bed beside him.

"Toby," she panted, "you weren't kidding when you said you were going to fuck my brains out"

"That's the next part." Toby chuckled stroking his erection, "lay on your stomach with your ass in the air"

Spencer obeyed and soon Toby was pushing into her from behind. He plunged his dick all the way in her making her near cum again.

"Who's pussy is it baby?" Toby asked as he pumped in to her.

"It's....yours....baby" Spencer panted between thrusts clawing her hands into her pillow.

"Say my name"

"Toby!"

"You want to cum?"

"Yes Toby please"

Toby began pounding into her getting her close to orgasm.

"I'm gonna cum in you" it wasn't a question as he held down her hips and pounded into her.

"Yes, fuck! say my name when you cum inside of me."

Spencer came as Toby began to shake and moan as he exploded inside her.

"Spencer, oh my fucking god I don't deserve you"

Toby finally climbed off of Spencer as she rode out the orgasm.

"When do your parents get home?" Toby asked surprising her by standing at the side of the bed and getting dressed.

"Late this afternoon" she said pulling his hand to bring him back to bed.

"I have some work to do" Toby said looking very sad he couldn't rejoin her, "besides you drained all my cum out"

Spencer hid behind a pillow in an attempt to hide her blush.

"The least I can do is walk you out" Spencer said climbing out of bed and dressing herself.

When they got to the back door Toby pulled her close into a deep kiss that became a make out session.

The sound of someone clearing their throat pulled them apart and they saw Melissa standing in the hallway to the front door with bags that Spencer guessed were wedding things.

"Sorry to interrupt" she said not looking sorry at all.

"Call you after work" Toby said pulling her into another heated kiss before moving to her ear away from Melissa and whispering, "I have something very special planned for us tonight." He kissed her ear before leaving.

"What the hell was that? Did he spend the night?!"

"We had a movie night" Spencer said trying to avoid the subject.

"Bull" Melissa said "I saw the way he kissed you just now that was real. Mom and dad aren't even here."

"Ok I'll tell you but you have to keep it a secret. This is not something I'm prepared to tell mom and dad."

"He made love to me last night"

"What?" Melissa asked looking genuinely shocked not knowing whether to be happy or horrified.

"But you said this was just to get mom off your back about Andrew Campbell, you slept with him?!"

"He's my best friend, I love him and he loves me, why is this a bad thing?"

"No, it's not a bad thing I just....." Melissa paused "hope he doesn't hurt you."

"He won't" Spencer said before distracting her sister about her wedding purchases.

****
A few hours later Spencer was sitting on the couch reading for class when the door bell rang. Since Melissa was on a date with her fiancé Spencer set the book down and headed to the door.

When she opened the door she thought she might be physically ill. She couldn't believe this man was standing at her doorstep with a bouquet of red roses and sunflowers.

"Hi baby" he said kissing her on the cheek and handing her the flowers.

"Alex...."

Dun dun dun! Who doesn't love a good cliffhanger? God knows I do! What do you think will happen next? Until next time my lovelies...