"It's so nice that we never actually have to plan Spencer's birthday parties" Hanna said as she, Ali, Emily, and Aria reached the Hastings back door. Toby had been planning her birthday parties since they were 12 practically and no one, not even her parents, ever complained. Peter and Veronica Hastings were drinking coffee at the island when the girls walked in.

"Hi girls" Veronica said pleasantly, "coffee anyone?"

Each girl nodded and the maid began preparing coffees. Ali checked her watch and furrowed her brow.

"Toby's late" she said looking at the girls. They knew he had some new secret girlfriend but blowing off Spencer's birthday planning was so unlike him.

"He's at the UPS store doing the invitations" Veronica said as Melissa walked in.

"Spencer's up to her eyeballs in Mom's legal documents we have plenty of time." She assured the nervous looking girls.

"Are you sure you guys want to be involved in the planning" Aria asked hesitantly, "it is Spencer's 21st birthday...."

"We're not under the illusion that our daughter doesn't drink" Peter said typing away.

"Did Toby tell anyone the theme? Maybe we could get started without him" Emily said sheepishly.

"You know he keeps it under lock and key until it's time to plan." Veronica shrugged.

"I can't wait to see which pictures she picked" Aria said. She had spent an entire afternoon taking pictures of the soon to be birthday girl.

Just then the door opened slightly and they took in Toby holding the door slightly ajar as he spoke with someone on the phone.

"Yeah, I'll pick you up tonight" they heard him say.

"Must be the new girlfriend" Hanna muttered to the girls.

"Yeah, can't wait" he said before hanging up the phone.

"Got a hot date Cavanaugh?" Alison said evilly "who's the hot mess this time?"

"That was Spencer, for your information, the old movie theater is playing a back to the future triple feature."

"Ignore her" Emily said waving Alison off, "we're dying to know this years theme."

"Ok," he said in a hushed whisper "this years theme is the 90s, costumes, music, decorations, everything 90s."

"There's no way my daughter agreed to this unless you mean the 1790s" Veronica said chuckling.

"Not only did she agree, she loved the idea" he said passing around the official invitations to everyone.

The blue postcard had a picture of Spencer dressed in what looked like only a mens dress shirt. The words sprawled above "Man! I feel like a woman!". In smaller text off to the side it stated the theme and location of the party which was Toby's loft apartment. The girls were taken aback by the scandalous pictures and poses of Spencer on the invitations.

After all the details had been hammered out the girls left as Toby said he had some other birthday plans to go over with her parents.

"Can you believe those pictures?!" Ali said to the group on the way to get coffee, "Aria, I can't believe you couldn't talk her out of such a trashy idea."

"Yeah, I didn't want to say anything in front of her parents or Toby but I didn't take those pictures"

"So she paraded around in only a button up shirt for some stranger?" Ali asked.

"I guess."

******
"Mr. and Mrs. Hastings," Toby began "I know you guys are meeting Melissa's fiancé on Saturday which is Spencer's birthday but one of her birthday presents is we're going to spend the weekend after her party in Philly." Toby said explaining about the comedy show tickets and the museum tickets. He smiled hoping they'd buy what he was saying. He had purchased tickets to the comedy show that part was true but Toby had every intention of spending the rest of their weekend in Philly making love to Spencer.

"Of course Toby" Veronica smiled as Peter just nodded, "it will probably be less stress for Melissa if we meet him first anyway"

After Toby left the Hastings, he got into the car itching to text Spencer, who had promised her mom she'd get a weeks worth of paperwork she'd been putting off done.

"I can't wait to lay you down tonight" he texted her low key loving the secrecy of their relationship.

"Toby.....you know I can't think straight when you talk to me like that"

"I'm sorry, I'll stop, just get to my place as soon as you can." Toby texted feeling himself stiffen inside his jeans. Thoughts of the last two weeks with Spencer swam in his head he wanted her so badly. When he got home he went to his bedroom. He let himself fantasize about going to Spencer's mom's office, bending her over the desk, pulling the dress up and her panties down.

"Oh fuck" he screamed stopping before he could complete the fantasy. He didn't want to cum in his hand, he wanted to come in Spencer.

"Baby please, I need you" He texted Spencer desperately.

"I'll be home in like and hour" Spencer said adding a kissy face emoji.

"I'm so fucking hard it hurts please baby"

Fifteen minutes later Spencer was walking through his door and Toby ran to meet her when he heard her key in the door. He pulled her inside kicking the door closed and locking it before kissing her.

"I'm gonna fuck you so hard" Toby said dragging her over to the counter and bending her over it. He slammed into her almost cumming at the feel of her wetness.

"I'm not the only one that's wanted to fuck all day huh?" Toby said reaching around to her front to rub her clit. "You're such a little whore for me aren't you?"

"Toby!" Spencer cried as he brought her close to orgasm.

"You know what I want to hear Spencer" Toby said as he edged her again "tell me you're my little whore"

"I'm your little whore" Spencer panted "your dripping wet little whore"

Toby drilled into Spencer making her cum hard as he followed along after. When they could finally pull apart Toby picked Spencer's spent body up and carried her to the bedroom.

"When you wake up I have an early birthday present for you" Toby whispered into her ear.

Spencer woke up a few hours later to the smell of steak coming from the kitchen. She pulled on a pajama set that now lived at Toby's and padded down to the kitchen.

"Steak?" Spencer yawned as she stretched grabbing a mug and pouring herself a cup of coffee.

"And mashed potatoes and corn" Toby added, "all your favorites"

"Wow, I feel so special" Spencer said wondering why he was going to all this trouble.

After dinner, Spencer cleaned up before joining Toby on the couch. On the table, was a medium sized box wrapped in red shimmery paper.

"Is that for me?" Spencer asked biting a nail. She had assumed the party and trip to Philly was her birthday present.

"It's for Philly mostly" Toby said looking nervous.

"Can I open it!" Spencer asked with a chuckle.

"In a minute" Toby said pulling her into his lap.

He kissed her gently before pulling away.

"I love you Spencer" Toby began and Spencer felt a knot in her stomach. She loved Toby she was sure she did but this was all new and sudden for both of them. "The last two weeks have been the best, we've become closer than I ever thought we would." The knot intensified as Spencer began to think he was ending their arrangement.

"I want us to be even closer" Toby said handing her the box, nodding that she could open it.
Spencer ripped into the paper tossing it aside to get at the box. She pulled a long piece of tape up, ripping the flaps from their place.

Inside were six strips of black fabric. Toby looked at her expectantly but she was lost.

"I don't understand" she said as she turned to him. Toby looked through the strips pulling out a shorter one that was wider than the others.

"This one is a blindfold" Toby said handing it to her. It only took Spencer a few minutes to figure out what the rest of the ties did and panic ran through her.

"So when we go to Philly, you're gonna tie me to the bed and blindfold me and gag me"

"Not gag you, not with one of these anyway" he said giving her a wink not noticing her terror.

"No"

"I'm sure it's a little different and scary from what you've done before but it might be fun."

"I said no, what the hell is wrong with you?!"

"That's not fair" Toby said trying to figure out why Spencer was so upset, tears streaming down her face, "don't cry we can put them away and never talk about it again."

"I have to go!" Spencer said standing up abruptly.

"Spencer you don't have to leave."

"For the first time ever, I don't feel safe here" Spencer cried running out the door.

Spencer's words played over and over in his head as he replayed the whole scene. By morning his head was pounding from one too many beers.

A knock so small Toby almost wrote off that he imagined it came from the door. When he opened it Spencer was on the other side, red puffy eyes staring back at him.

"Baby, I'm so sorry" he said opening his arms to her, his heart swelling when she walked into the embrace.

"I have to tell you something" she whispered after a few minutes.

"Spencer the silence is killing me" Toby said after he'd sat silently beside her on the couch for at least five minutes."

"I never told you because I knew what you would do" Spencer said pausing, "when I was fifteen, the girls and I went to a frat party. I had too much to drink and I went to go lay down in a room upstairs."

Toby wanted to beg her to stop right where she was because he knew where this was going and he didn't want to hear.

"This guy came in, he clamped a hand over my mouth, and he held me down" Spencer cried out.

Toby pulled her into his lap rocking her and shushing her. "You don't half to say anymore, I understand"

After a few minutes Spencer spoke again.

"I wanted to tell you after it happened but"

"I would've killed him." Toby said "I would have beat him within an inch of his fucking life."

Spencer had always known this would be Toby's reaction but to hear him say it out loud turned her on. She sat in the comfort of his embrace before pulling out of it.

"I'm going to go upstairs, get undressed, and get in your bed, and you're going to come upstairs and make love to me all night long."

"Whatever you want" Toby agreed kissing her softly.

Spencer climbed into his lap, straddling him and deepening the kiss. After a few minutes in a heated make out Spencer pulled away from Toby with a waiting expression, sure any minute he would carry her up to his bed.

"Take your clothes off" he said his voice husky.

"Right here?" Spencer asked looking around remembering how Hanna had just walked in the other day.

"Right here."

Spencer very shyly began unbuttoning the front of her shirt.

"You are so beautiful" he said cupping her breasts sitting perfectly in a silky white bra. Spencer had just slipped her button down off when a knock came from the door.

"Go away!" Toby yelled towards the door.

"Toby, come on man, I need your help. I told Hanna I could fix her car but I think I made it worse. She'll kill me if she finds out I fucked it up."

Toby hung his head sighing as Spencer hurried up and pulled her shirt on buttoning it hastily. She grabbed the tv remote turning on the stream menu making it look like they'd been watching tv as Toby walked over to the door.

"So anyway it was making this sound like...." Caleb stopped in his tracks noticing Spencer "Hey Spencer, I'm not interrupting anything am I"

"No, just me making toby watch "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" again" Spencer said trying to act casual as Caleb grabbed a banana from the fruit bowl on the counter. He looked at her curiously and Spencer was worried he'd heard them.

"We gonna go fix Hanna's car or what" Toby said irritated. Caleb nodded heading for the door.

"You missed a button" Caleb said to Spencer before heading out the door. Spencer hurriedly fixed her shirt even though they'd left.

*******

"Why exactly did you tell Hanna you could fix her car?" Toby asked as he checked out the car.

"Her and her mom have been having financial troubles. I thought it was an easy fix. She would've freaked if I came back and said I caused it to have more issues."

Toby said nothing and continued to work on the car.

"I'm telling you man. Girlfriends are the worst. Lately I've been thinking maybe you have the right idea. Get in. Get off. Get out. No muss. No fuss."

Toby stood up straightening his back looking him dead in the eyes.

"Excuse me?"

"Come on you go through women like you're fucking Hugh Hefner" Caleb joked clearly not noticing how offended Toby was.

"You're an idiot" Toby said rolling his eyes, "Hanna loves you and if you think you're gonna have it better, you're out of your mind."

"So why do you do it? Sleep around?" Caleb asked.

"Haven't found someone I wanted to spend more than two hours with." Toby lied trying not to think of the petite brunette at his apartment and all the things he could be doing to her right now.

"So you want a girlfriend?"

"Yes, and until then I'll just hook up with whoever when the opportunity arises."

Two and a half hours later Hanna's car was running perfectly and Toby was ready to leave sure Spencer was sound asleep by now.

"Thanks man" Caleb said shaking Toby's hand "I can't thank you enough for doing this for me."

"I didn't do it for you" Toby said pausing "I did it for Hanna"

********
Spencer was laying on the couch when Toby got back.

"I started touching myself and got so horny" she told him with an evil smile.

"I'm going to go shower and then I'll take care of you." Toby said heading upstairs. He was just about to get in the shower when Spencer came in. She began undressing slowly.

"Stop" Toby said loudly.

"What's wrong?" Spencer said with a frown wondering why he was angry with her.

" I wanted tonight to be nice and slow. I wanted to use my mouth, my hands, and then let you control the ride."

"Okay so what's the problem?"

"I want to fuck your brains out right now" Toby said breathing heavily "I want to nail you to my fucking bed."

Spencer went back to taking her clothes off.

"Then do it" she said "fuck my brains out. Nail me to the bed."

"Is this just sex to you?!" Toby blurted out "because I'm fucking in love with you."

"I love you, I'm in love with you too." Spencer said  shedding a few tears at finally admitting it. Toby fell to his knees wrapping his arms around her waist kissing her belly.

"Whatever you want to do to me, do it. Just go easy on me in Philly."

"Philly?"

"I trust you, more than I've trusted any man I've slept with, you can tie me to the bed, just....go....slow."

Toby pulled Spencer into the shower bending her  over in front of him as he slammed into her.

"You must've played with yourself quite a lot to get this wet," Toby said chuckling "did you make yourself cum?"

"Yes" Spencer panted as Toby slammed into her again. He grabbed her hips railing on her pussy as her moans got higher and higher pitched. Toby watched her get squirmy as orgasm got close. He stopped the pumping and Spencer whined unsatisfied.

Toby turned her to face him and he picked her up. "I want to look in your eyes as I cum in your pussy."

Toby held Spencer against the wall as he pumped into her harder and faster. The sounds of her getting close to orgasm made toby pump harder.

"Oh baby" Spencer cried "cum inside me"

Toby continued to pump into trying to stop himself from exploding inside Spencer before he was ready.

"You're gonna make me cum Toby, I'm gonna cum so hard."

"Cum!" Toby said through gritted teeth trying to hold off his orgasm "cum all over my cock."

Spencer screamed as she came.

"I love you so fucking much! Cum inside me!"

********

"You fixed the car!" Hanna said clapping excitedly.

"It was an easy fix, no problem." Caleb said brushing off her praise.

"Can I ask you something" Caleb said after a minute. "You said Toby had a new gf, do you have proof?"

"No but I know he does."

"Don't say anything to your friends" Caleb said
"I think he and Spencer are screwing."