Evelyn

I got home from work today. "I'm home!" I said. I shut my door, locking it. I don't see or hear Lexi at all.

"Lexi?" I asked. I went to her room and she wasn't there. I walked to my kitchen, opening my fridge.

I grabbed some leftover penne alfredo pasta that Lexi made for us. I closed the fridge, seeing a note on the fridge door.

'Evie, I'm staying at Colby's house for the night. Won't be home until tomorrow. Enjoy the leftover penne. -Lexi'

I took the note off the fridge, throwing it away. I put the pasta in the microwave, warming it up for 2 minutes.

Five minutes later...

I finished eating my leftovers, washing my plate in the sink, rinsing it off. My phone vibrated, it's a text from Jensen.

'Meet me in the elevator.' I replied; 'Be right there'. I took my phone off the charger.

I grabbed my keys. I locked my apartment door, heading to the elevator.

I pushed the up button. The elevator door opens, I see Jensen standing there.

He looks very pissed. I went inside the elevator. "Turn around," Jensen said. I turned around, facing the elevator doors.

I felt something going over my eyes. "Jensen, what are you doing?" I asked, confused.

"I'm blindfolding you," he said. "Why? I can't even see," I said.

"Your punishment is a surprise," he said. I sighed angrily. "I hate surprises," I said.

"Well, then you shouldn't have lied to me, silly whore," he whispered. The elevator doors dinged.

Jensen

I lead Evie to my apartment while she's blindfolded. I opened my door, leading her inside.

I shut my door, locking it. I put her over my shoulder, taking her to my room.

I put her down on her feet. "Stand here," I whispered.

Evie nodded. "Take your shoes off," I whispered. She got down untying her converse and taking them off.

I start slowly stripping her down to her bra and thong. I got on my knees, taking them off.

I stood back up, taking her bra off. "Now what?" she asked. I grabbed her neck.

"Don't speak until I say you can," I said. Evie nodded.

"Hold your hands out," I said. She holds her hands out, I cuffed her hands together.

"Lay down," I said. Evie laid down. I put her hands over her head.

"Keep your hands over your head, don't move them. Nod if you understand," I said.

Evie nodded. I smirked softly, taking my shirt off. I brought some stuff from the Herogasm set.

I grabbed a vibrator out, turning it on.
Evie kept her hands over her head.

I start teasing her body with it. Evie starts flinching her body, moaning.

I moved it to her breast, over her nipple as it got hard. "Jensen, what the fuck?" she asked.

"This is your punishment. I'm not gonna fuck you until you to know how I felt when I heard about you and Jack," I said.

I moved the vibrator to her clit, teasing her. Evie moaned softly, I kissed her.

"Jensen," she moans. I teased her pussy back and forth.

"This is how you make me feel," I whispered, pulling the vibrator away.

"Jensen, please don't tease me like this," she said, begging. "See frustrating, isn't it?" I asked.

I turned up the vibrator to make it vibrate faster. I moved the vibrator away again.

"Jensen, please stop! Red! Please stop!" she said, using her safe word. I stopped, shutting the vibrator off.

I uncuffed her hands. She quickly sat up, taking the blindfold off.

She grabbed a blanket, covering herself and sniffling. "That wasn't a punishment, Jensen. That was you getting revenge for lying to you," she said.

"You told me that you're at Sneaky Dees alone. Then your roommate tells me that you were sleeping. Why did you lie to me," I asked.

"Jensen, if I told you about Jack and I hang out, I knew you'd get mad," she said. "Yeah, I would. Plus when Karl told me about you and Jack instead of you telling me. I felt like I was punched in the stomach. You don't know what it feels like," I said.

"Why do you fucking care about who I'm hanging with or whatever I do?" she asked. "Because...," I paused.

"Because why?!" she yelled. "Because I am in love with you!" I said. She looked at me.

"You what?" she asked. "I'm in love with you, Evie," I said.

I looked at him. "Since when?" she asked.

"Since that night I rescued you and we danced passionately as if no one was around. When I heard that song that I requested, it made me remember that night. Then I heard that song by Little Mix, it made me realize that I am in love with you," I said.

"What song by Little Mix made you realized you were in love with me?" she asked. "It was called Secret Love Song. It reminds me of when we're in public and we can't show affection but only behind closed doors," I said.

"Jensen, you can't be in love with me, you're married. Does Danneel know this?" she said.

"Yes, Danneel knows," I said. "How did she know?" she asked.

"I told her that I was in love with you," I said. Evie nodded.

"So after listening to the part; 'Why can't I say I'm in love. I wanna shout it from the rooftop', it made me realize I was in love with you," I said.

Evie sighed looking at me. "Evie, say something," I said. "I don't know what to say," she said, looking away from me.

"Evie, come on. Tell me that you have feelings for me too," I said. "I do have feelings for you. I care for you as well. However, I don't want you to throw away 11 years of marriage to Danneel like that. I don't want to be the reason why your marriage ended," she said.

I grabbed Evie's chin, making her look at me. "You're not, Evie. It's all about what my heart wants. My heart wants you," I said.

"What do you want me to do? Stop seeing Jack?" she asked. "I didn't say that, Evie. I don't want you to stop seeing him. You're right, I can't control everything you do," I said.

"Good. If you're really in love with me, you have to trust me," she said. "I trust you, Evie, I don't want to see you get hurt," I said.

Evie nodded. "Jensen, just trust me," she said, kissing my cheek. I look at her, smiling.

"I want to confess something to you," she said. I looked at her. "Okay," I said.

"I hate to admit this but I actually missed you," she whispered. I looked at her, smiling.

"You did?" I asked, smiling. "Like everyday. Did you miss me," she asked, chuckling.

"Yes, I missed you too," I said, kissing her, cupping my face. She kissed me back, holding my wrist.

I break the kiss, looking at her. "I have one question," I said.

"What?" she asked. "How much did you miss my big cock?" I asked. "So badly," she said.

"That's my girl. Want to finish what we started? Without the vibrator and blindfold?" I asked.

"Now, there's Jensen that I missed. The soft and sweet side of him, not the vengeful and jealous Jensen," she said, smiling.

I kissed her deeply, she kissed me back. I pulled her over my lap, straddling me.

I grabbed the blanket, taking it off her. I kissed her deeply.

I grabbed her leg, turning us over. I laid her down on the bed, I kissed her deeply.

She kissed me back. I slowly kissed down her neck to her breast, sucking on them.

She moans softly, running her finger through my hair. I bit her nipple.

She moaned louder. I went to suck on the other one. She moaned softly.

I continued to kiss down her body, her little pudgy belly. "I missed your beautiful body. Even your podgy belly," I whispered, keeping going.

"I missed your touches," she whispered. "Good girl," I whispered, start spreading Evie's legs apart, start caressing her clit.

"Looks like that vibrator made you wet," I said. "That's what happens when you tease me like that," she whispers.

"I know," I said, start eating her pussy out. Evie moaned softly, she looked at me.

I rub her clit while licking faster. "Fuck!" Evie moaned softly.

I started motorboating her clit, her moans grew louder. I looked at her, start tongue fucking her pussy.

"Oh, Jensen. How I missed your tongue," she moaned. I looked at her.

"Did you miss me doing this?" I asked, putting both her legs on my shoulders. I moved us to the side of her bed, she held onto my head.

I quickly lifted her off her bed, into a powerbomb move. "Oh fuck, I missed this so much," she said.

I start tongue fucking her pussy again. Evie moans louder as she still holds onto me.

"Jensen, I want to suck your cock," she said. I gently power bombed her down while still holding her.

I stood up, she sat up. She grabbed my cock, started stroking and sucking.

I grabbed her by the hair, making her head move faster. She starts making gag sounds.

"Ohh, fuck! Where did you learn that?" I asked. She pulled away, looking at me.

"I watched some porn and learned it," she said. "Good girl," I said.

She spit on my cock, and continued to suck. I started thrusting in her mouth, she made more gag sounds and slurping sounds.

"Oh fuck, Evie, I miss your fucking mouth," I said.

Minutes later

Evie's on top of me, riding me. I grabbed her breast, squeezing them as she rode me.

I lifted my hips, thrusting in her pussy. She moaned louder as I went a little faster.

I laid back down, grabbing her hips. She grinded faster on my cock, kissing me deeply.

I quickly rolled us over. "Pound me like you bashed that blood bag with your shield," she whispered.

"With pleasure," I said. I moved her knees to her chest, then thrusting and pounding my cock deep into her pussy.

She started clawing my back, I groaned with pleasure as she does that with her nails.

I still pounding her pussy harder, kissing her deeply. We muffled our moans as I went a little rougher.

I felt her hands moving down my lower back, I felt her nails in my back.
I groaned loudly.

I went a lot faster and harder, groaning as I was close. Evie moaned louder as my cock hit her g-spot.

I felt her cum all over my cock as I pounded her harder and faster, I started groaning as I am about to cum inside her.

"Fuck, I'm gonna cum!" I moaned, thrusting faster. "Cum in me," she whispered.

I went a little faster and harder. I moaned and groaned louder as I came inside her pussy.

Evie and I started breathing heavily, I pulled out of her pussy. My cum slowly came out of her pussy.

I laid down as she started catching her breath. We laid next to each other.

---

Evie and I are still in my bed, cradling her in my arms. We were still naked, holding each other.

She touched my chest, feeling my heart. "Your heart's still beating fast," she said.

"I know it's letting me know that my heart is wanting more of you," I said, looking at her. "Do you want me to say it back?" she asked.

"Only if you mean it," I said. "So what do we do for tomorrow?" she asked.

"You and Jack can continue seeing each other," I said. Evie nodded.

"Then I will always come back to you," she said. "I like that deal," I said, kissing her.

She kissed me back. "I love you, Evie," I whispered.

Evie smiles softly, kissing me back. "I know," she whispered.

She kissed me deeply. I kissed her back. "Since your back, what should we do?" she asked.

"Nothing. I just wanted to lay next to you, cuddling. It sucks not seeing you for a week," I said. Evie nodded, pulling the covers over us.

I held her in my arms, kissing her head. "I really missed you," she said.

"I missed you too, baby," I said. Evie breathing calmed, so has mine.

She closed her eyes. We both fell asleep in each other's arms.