Note: The first 5 titles and 7 reigns he won (collectively amongst all 5 titles) were as a part of the 2K19 MyCareer Mode, and the Epilogue afterwards.

WWE United States Championship - Won 2 times, 1 time in the 2K19 MyCareer Mode and 1 time in 2K20 - Reign 1: 8 weeks and 2 days/58 days (with 6 successful defences (if you count the DQ retains as well)) - Reign 2: 8+ weeks/56+ days/Current Champion in 2k20 (with 1 successful defence).

Undisputed Hardcore Championship - Won 2 times, 1 time in 2K19 MyCareer Mode and created the title in his feud with The Miz and 1 time in 2K19 outside of the MyCareer Mode, also he is the first 2 time champion - Reign 1: 6 days (with 2 successful defences) - Reign 2: 4 weeks/28 days.

WWE Intercontinental Championship - Won 1 time and held for 3 weeks/21 days (with 1 successful defence).

WWE Universal Championship 2016 to 2019 version - Won 2 times - Reign 1: 4 weeks/28 days - Reign 2: 6 weeks and 1 day/43 days (with 1 successful defence).

WWE Championship 2014 to Current version - Won 2 times as La Fenix Ultimo - Reign 1: 1 week/7 days - Reign 2: 5+ weeks/35+ days (with 4 successful title defences).

WWE 24/7 Championship - Won 1 time for 1 week/7 days (with 1 successful defence).

ROH World Television Championship 2018 to Current version - Won 3 times, twice as La Fenix Ultimo and 1 time as The Deceiver - Reign 1: 12 weeks/84 days (with 1 successful defence) - Reign 2: 9 weeks/63 days - Reign 3: 2+ weeks/14+ days/Current Champion in 2K19.

WWE Smackdown Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time as La Fenix Ultimo with El Mago as part of the team "The Magical Fenix" for 18 weeks/126 days (with 2 successful defences).

WWE Intercontinental Championship 1998 to 2011 version - Won 1 time as La Fenix Ultimo for 6 weeks/42 days.

Lord of Darkness Championship - Won 1 time as The Deceiver for 28 weeks/196 days (with 5 successful title defences).

NXT Tag Team Championships 2012 to 2017 versions - Won 2 times, 1 time with Keith Lee as part of the team "Limitless Fenix" (with 2 successful defences) and 1 time with El Wolfenstein as part of the team "Phoenix Wolves" (with 1 successful defence) - Reign 1: 19 weeks/133 days - Reign 2: 8 weeks/56 days.

Shattered World Championship - Won 1 time as The Deceiver for 14 weeks/98 days (with 1 successful defence).

WWE Intercontinental Championship 2019 to Current version - Won 1 time as La Fenix Ultimo for 22 weeks/154 days (with 3 successful defences).

Other Accolades:

A 5* Submissions Match against Chad Gable, the latter winning the match, on WWE Raw days before facing John Cena at WWE Summerslam.

A 5* Star Match, surprisingly, against Jinder Mahal in a bloodied 15-Minute Iron Man Match when he won his first WWE Championship, 8 days after losing his 2nd Universal Championship, where he barely won with a score of 4-3.

A 5* Star Match against Randy Orton at an episode of WWE Smackdown Live 9 days after Money In The Bank in a 15-Minute Iron Man Match that saw both competitors bleeding massively, and also ended in a time limit draw with the scores at 4-4.

Won a Gold Rush Tournament for the vacant ROH World Television Championship in 2K19.

[As of 16/05/2020]