ECW World Heavyweight Championship 2006 to 2008 version - Won 1 time, and held for 84 weeks/588 days.

IWGP Heavyweight Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 2 weeks/14 days.

WWE/nWo Championship - Won 1 time, was the first and only champion, and held for 5 weeks/35 days (with 1 successful defence).

Impact X Division Championship 2017 to 2018 version - Won 1 time, and held for 42 weeks/294 days.

Lucha Underground Gift of the Gods Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 20 weeks/140 days.

ROH World Television Championship 2018 to Current version - Won 1 time, and held for 31 weeks/217 days.

Undisputed World Championship - Won 3 times - Reign 1: 5 weeks/35 days - Reign 2: 13 weeks/91 days (with 3 successful defences) - Reign 3: 1 week/7 days.

ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Championships 2018 to Current versions - Won 3 times, 1 time with John Cyclone and Bare Bones as part of the "nWo Blood Brothers", and 2 times with "The King of Destruction" Destroyer and The Test/Subject 115 as part of the stable "nWo Hit Squad!" - Reign 1: 8 weeks/56 days - Reign 2: 17 weeks/119 days (with 3 successful defences) - Reign 3: 10 weeks/70 days (with 1 successful defence).

NEVER Openweight 6-Man Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time with "The King of Destruction" Destroyer and The Test/Subject 115 as part of the stable "The Hit Squad!", and held for 40 weeks/280 days.

NEVER Openweight Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 62 weeks/434 days (with 3 successful defences).

ROH World Championship 2017 to Current version - Won 1 time, and held for 99 weeks/693 days (with 10 successful title defences).

ROH World Championship [The first version of the title] - Won 1 time, and held for 10 weeks/70 days (with 1 successful defence).

IWGP Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time with "The King of Destruction" Destroyer as part of "The Hit Squad!", and held for 78 weeks/546 days.

Defiant World Championship - Won 2 times - Reign 1: 14 weeks/98 days - Reign 2: 99 weeks/693 days.

ECW World Television Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 18 weeks/126 days.

ICW Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time with "The Dark Savior" Nightmare, and held for 38 weeks/266 days.

ICW Zero-G Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 15 weeks/105 days.

IWGP Junior Heavyweight Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 29 weeks/203 days.

IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time with Rich Swann, and held for 16 weeks/112 days.

ROH World Television Championship 2012 to 2018 version - Won 1 time, and held for 52 weeks 364 days.

Undisputed Championship - Won 1 time and was the last champion, and held for 1 week/7 days.

WCW Cruiserweight Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 5 weeks/35 days.

WCW Hardcore Championship - Won 2 times - Reign 1: 5 weeks/35 days - Reign 2: 16 weeks/112 days.

WCW World Heavyweight Championship 1991 to 1993 version - Won 2 times.

WCW World Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time with his best friend Kyle Storm as part of the team "Go To RKO".

WCPW Hardcore Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 4 weeks/28 days.

WWE Championship 2005 to 2013 version - Won 1 time, and held for 10 weeks/70 days (with 1 successful title defence) 

Fun Fact: This was the first major championship that Andrew won, and he won it on a night were he was in 3 different title matches: a bloodied WWE United States Championship match to open the event (which he lost), a WWE Tag Team Championship tag title match that took place right afterwards (which he won), and then a WWE Championship match against Rey Mysterio.

WWE Championship 2013 to 2014 version - Won 4 times - Reign 1: 4 week/28 days - Reign 2: 36 weeks/252 days - Reign 3: 8 weeks/56 days - Reign 4: 4 weeks/28 days.

WWE Championship [Winged Eagle version] - Won 1 time.

WWE Championship [Brahma Bull version] - Won 1 time, and held for 1 week/7 days.

WWE Cruiserweight Championship 2002 to 2007 version - Won 1 time, but as a manager for his best friend Kyle Storm, but was treated as co-champion for a time.

WWE Intercontinental Championship - Won 4 times - Reign 1: 8 weeks/56 days - Reign 2: 12 weeks/84 days - Reign 3: 12 weeks/84 days - Reign 4: 4 weeks/28 days.

WWE Smackdown Tag Team Championships - Won 1 time with "The Fallen One" Jack Ryan as part of the team "The Fallen Family", and held for 5 weeks/35 days.

WWE Tag Team Championships 2002 to 2010 versions - Won 1 time with his best friend Kyle Storm as part of the team "Go To RKO".

WWE Undisputed Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 1 week/7 days.

WWE Tag Team Championships 2010 to 2016 version/WWE Unified Tag Team Championships/WWE Raw Tag Team Championships - Won 11 times, 1 time with "The Playboy 69" Adam Sandmann, 1 time with John "Bradshaw" Layfield/JBL, 1 time with "The Fallen One" Jack Ryan as part of the team "Team Dark Powers", and 8 times with his best friend Kyle Storm as part of the team "Go To RKO" - Reign 1: 9 weeks/63 days - Reign 2: N/A - Reign 3: 10 weeks/70 days - Reign 4: N/A - Reign 5: 36 weeks/252 days - Reign 6: 0 weeks/0 days - Reign 7: 48 weeks/336 days - Reign 8: 20 weeks/140 days - Reign 9: 4 weeks/28 days - Reign 10: 100 weeks - 700 days - Reign 11: N/A.

WWE United States Championship - Won 11 times.

WWE Universal Championship 2016 to 2019 version - Won 1 time, and held for 9 weeks/63 days.

World Heavyweight Championship - Won 1 time, and held for 58 weeks - 406 days.

WWE World Tag Team Championships 1998 to 2002 versions - Won 1 time with Paul Wright, and held for 14 weeks/98 days.

[As of 17/05/2020]