Candy:Last time on total drama island, the merge are chained each other. They found wooden heads of the loser contestants and joltik is insulting them one by one and she is automatically eliminated for the game. Who will win and who will lose? Find out right here right now on total drama island!!!!!! The cannonball hits komajiro's trailer and destroys it, much to his surprise and disappointment. She then announces that all campers need to report to the amphitheater for their next challenge in a stereotypical pirate accent.
Candy:Arrgh!!!!! Avast there me scurvy dogs!!! Today's challenge is search and do not destroy!!!
Rowlf:So how do we do this? Candy tells him that he had a good question and then he continues to explain that they will be looking for keys to treasure chests, which contain rewards. He then invites them up to pull clues out of a bucket, which is held out by Chef jojo. The campers do so, while candy explains that the clues they pick will have a drawing that gives them a hint of where their key is hidden in the camp. Rowlf reveals that he had picked out the clue containing a picture of a bear, something he is extremely intimidated by. Candy interjects by saying that he had been hoping rowlf would get that clue. Candy then looks at animal's clue, which is of chef jojo's refrigerator. Candy then tells him that Chef jojo brushes it every day for fingerprints, which also intimidates him. Zorch is looking at his drawing, which candy reveals to be of the septic tank for the communal washrooms. Candy then tells the group to go find their keys and return with them by "6:00 pm, eastern standard time", prompting the campers then disperse. Animal is then seen in the confessional, wondering who came up with the "stupid challenge" and also mentioned to candy that, in his opinion, pirate tights are not flattering for her legs. Rowlf is then shown in the confessional, excited over the challenge, although he does admit the bears are "a little concerning," though he seems too excited over the prospect of treasure to dwell on the thought of bears too much. Next, kermit is shown working on retrieving his key from the man-eating shark-infested lake. He manages to lure the sharks away from the post where the key is by throwing a fish far off into the lake, before diving in and quickly retrieving it. He exits the lake and calls his challenge "too easy", while zorch, who has been watching nervously the entire time, smiles and blushes. Meanwhile, animal is shown to be trying to get her key from Chef jojo’s refrigerator. He enters the kitchen nervously and walks over to the fridge, attempting to open it without being noticed. Once the door is ajar, he finds Chef jojo, holding an exceptionally large knife, inside, looking at him menacingly. He slowly closes the door, frightened and shocked, and walks out of the kitchen.
Zorch is then shown attempting to remove his key from a skunk hole. He looks at it from a distance, covering his face and moaning at the prospect of having to deal with the skunks. Gonzo then walks up next to him asking if he is okay. He replies that skunks "totally freak him out", to which he replies with an offer to help him, as he already has his key. He says that his challenge is "practically impossible," before kermit has the idea of pouring water down the hole, and flushing them out, which he does, successfully. Zorch then asks if skunks can swim, and when Trent responds positively, he responds with a dreamy "cool". The couple of friends then smiles at each other. Meanwhile, scooter is shown helping animal complete his challenge by lowering her by rope into Chef jojo’s kitchen while Chef jojo is sleeping. Animal manages to slip down without being noticed, and grabs his key. He is then slowly being pulled back up on the rope, when scooter sees a bug and lets the rope slip. Animal screams in shock, and ends up dropping his key, which he barely manages to grab again, before he and scooter regain control over the rope. Surprisingly, Chef jojo is not awakened by this outburst, and animal is able to exit the kitchen and keep the key in his possession. Gonzo and zorch are then shown, putting gonzo's plan to flush the skunks out of their hole into action, laughing together while doing so. Their plan works perfectly, allowing zorch to remove his key from the hole. Zorch is then shown in the confessional, saying that it was "moderately cool" for Trent to have helped him, acting like it is not a big deal to his and saying he is "okay". He then back tracks and excitedly says that he is "more than okay" and that he is "so incredible." But then says to the camera to not tell anyone she said that. Gonzo is shown in the confessional following him, saying that zorch being "so smart and independent" and "incredible to look at" is making him nuts, and adds that he "rocks his world" and that he would help him any day.  After that bentley arrived out of nowhere and he kissed animal. Bentley found a flaming hoop, which seems to be a minor task for him. Gonzo is then shown climbing a tree, attempting to remove his key from where it is tied on one of the branches, without much success. Hiro is shown next, inside the communal bathrooms, where he is putting on a snorkel and stepping into the toilet, in an effort to begin his search of the septic tank. Scooter is shown after Hiro, looking towards the beehive in which he is supposed to retrieve his key. Baymax then joins him and silently offers to help, walking towards the beehive. He returns several seconds later holding the key, but covered in bees, which then begin to chase scooter. Scooter runs straight to the dock, and jumps off, in order to avoid the mob of bees, while baymax wishes him luck. Rowlf is then shown attempting to confront the bear who possesses a key around his neck. While trying to quickly remove the key, the sleeping bear then forces rowlf to become stuck next to it, when it wraps its arm around him. Baymax is shown next, trying to talk to the snake which he needs to obtain his key from. He begins to tell it how cute it is when it bites him on the head, which leads him to call it "feisty". When the snake’s bite causes him to fall to the ground, animal walks up next to him saying that there is "no time for that now" as they need to have an alliance meeting. Animal and baymax are then shown meeting a bee-sting-covered scooter on the dock. In 17 hours later they open the treasure chests. Hiro receives chips and a candy bar, to which he asks if that is the best they can do, and candy replies by nodding. Rowlf is then shown, not able to open any chests with his key, which angers him. He then requests they do something about the bear, which, at that point, had the majority of rowlf’s body in its mouth. They then tranquilize the bear and, accidentally, rowlf. Zorch is then shown looking over the toaster he had received, while bentley pulled out a gift basket with an ‘Invincibility card’ included in it, earning his many glares from gonzo and baymax. Scooter is then shown receiving two bottles of, presumably, soda, but when he turns around, animal is glaring at him, holding his oddly-shaped lamp, while scooter, holding an accordion, bites his lip. Hiro is then shown receiving ‘Cleaver body spray', which candy claims "cuts through the stink". Geoff appears to be happy with the cologne.
Candy:Animal is officially eliminated. She catapult animal in the sky.
Kermit:Poor animal.
Gonzo:Yeah. He is our friend. I hope that he will be okay.
Bentley:What strange baby. Rowlf kicked bentley in the eye.
Rowlf:Jerk. Hmmph!!!!
Bentley:Ouch!