Tomura Shigaraki: (I'm never sure how to write for Shigaraki so sorry if he's written out of character.)

He was quick to pull his hand away, looking at you with an "are you trying to die?!" expression before asking you what the hell you are doing. When you said he's the one who held his hand out, he would have facepalmed but the hand against his face was in his way so he just gestured to the item, saying he was referring to that. When you argued he should say it then, he argued back he thought you would understand.

Kurogiri:

Your hand just went through making you both stare at it before you chuckled and said you forgot he has no hand to hold. He just shook his head with a little amused look before telling you he was gesturing to the item aside you.

Dabi:

He will just chuckle in amusement, saying he wanted the thing aside you. When you told him to be say it then and not just hold his hand out, he carelessly shrugged, saying he wasn't really in the mood to speak and be specific.

Himiko Toga:

She will let out a confused noise before giggling and swinging her arms around you, saying you you are so cute. So after she was done fangirling over how adorable that was of you, she took the item, waving it and saying she wanted this.