Logan- He would try to logic his way out of the scary situations. When the other Sides suggested watching horror movies, he immediately said no, for Virgil's sake.

Virgil- Poor Virgil... he would be a total mess, and having anxiety attacks a LOT. He'd be curled up in a ball, screaming and cussing.

Patton- He would be trying to comfort everyone but he would still get scared.

Roman- Roman would try to act like he is not scared. He'd still scream and be scared.

Remus- He would have an ABSOLUTE FIELD DAY.