Jeff the Killer: Jeffery Woods

Ben Drowned: Benjamin Lawman

Ticci Toby: Tobias Rogers

Homicidal Liu: Liu Woods

Sully: Sullivan Harrison

Luring Lyra: Lyra Rogers

Sally Williams: Salina Williams

Sam Williams: Samuel Williams

Lucille Stoner: Lucille Stoner

Milo the Electrocuted: Milo Moretti

Hung Iris: Iris Phang

Clockwork: Natalie Oulette

Zero: Zero (Alice Ndlovu)

Alma Richardson: Alma Richardson

Vailly Evans: Vailly Evans

Nathan the Nobody: Nathaniel Lux

Crystal the Hidden: Crystal Lux

Eyeless Jack: John Nichols

Lost Silver: Hitori Fujikawa

Kate the Chaser: Katelyn Milens

Charlie Matheson: Charlie Matheson Jr.

Rouge: Heather Marshall

Wilson the Basher: Wilson Pabhu

X-Virus: Cody Pulman

Masky: Tim Wright

Hoodie: Brian Thomas

Alex: Alexander Kralie

Jay: Jay Merrick

Seth: Seth Wilson

Sarah: Sarah Reid

Amy: Amy Locke (maiden name Walters)

Jessica: Jessica Locke

Stripes: Stripes/Eloise Lambros

Lazari: Lazari Swann

Red Death: Sifreid Gadriel

Gas Mask Maid: Marion Gadriel (maiden name Hawkins)

Bleedingman: Alexander Grant

Shadow Walker: Roger Wheatley

Jane the Killer: Jane Richardson

Mary Vaughn: Mary Vaughn Richardson

Nina the Killer: Nina Otis (maiden name Hopkins)

Puppeteer: Jonathan Blake

Bloody Painter: Helen Otis

Judge Angel: Dina Angela Clark

Suicide Sadie: Sadie Blake (maiden name Jakobsson)

Zachary the Proxy: Zachary Gibson

Rosemary: Rosemary Gibson (maiden name Masterson)

Nurse Ann: Ann Faheem

Kagekao: (unknown)

Jason the Toymaker: Jason Mayer

Killing Kate: Katherine Adler (maiden name De Herrera)

Chris the Revenant: Christine Myers

Randy: Randy Harrison

Keith: Keith Harrison (maiden name Brahms)

Troy: Troy Green

Prowler: Lucas Oulette

David Felton: David Felton

Laughing Jack: Laughing Jack

Isaac Grossman: Isaac Grossman

Raven: Manon Plume

Sammy Kingsley: Samuel Kingsley

Lulu: Lucille-Tiffany Greatfield

Dollmaker: Vine Voliakov

Svetlana: Svetlana Voliakov

Candy Pop: Candy Pop

OCs

S.O.S.: Sloan Nielsen

Ella: Ella Brahms

Indigo: Indigo Brahms

Odessa: Odessa Brahms (maiden name Ivanchenko)

Engine: Chase Pierson

Ace of Spades: Celeste Adler

The Mourning: Brittany Winchester

Harbinger: Francis Sandalo

Quentin: Quentin Atjuk

SweetNightTerrors's OCs

Theo Hunter: Theo Hunter

Rapid Fire: Jolene Burke