( this is a Alternate ending to Season 1 episode 8. If you haven't watched it then I suggest you go watch first for reading this cuz this may contain spoilers )

~~ Haruhi's pov ~~

I was shivering from the cold ocean water that Tamaki saved me from. I was going to thank him, but he grabbed me by the shoulders and yelled angrily,

"Why did you confront them?! What made tou think that you would stand a chance?!"

His lavendar eyes were just filled with rage. It was actually kind of frightening. But I wouldnt let my fear show to the blonde.

"There wasnt any time to think. I was there and I had to help‐" I try to reply calmly, but I was rudely interrupted by Tamaki

"That's no Excuse, You idiot! Dont forget, Your a Girl!" He yelled. I was getting frustrated my his sexist statements.

"Look, I'm sorry you had to come and save me, Tamaki. But I dont understand why your so mad at me right now. I dont think I did anything wrong!" My frustration laced my word as I spoke.

The guys all stared at me as if I was stupid for saying that.

"Listen Haruhi, Dont go around thinking that your special! Your not a marital arts master like Mori or Honey senpai! So just stay in your place where you belong!" Tamaki yelled.

Everyone gasps a little, even Mori... that was the final straw.

" 'Stay in my place' huh? Then maybe I shouldn't even be in the Host Club!" I yelled and shoved Tamaki off of me. I was so mad now. I usually kept my cool in situations like this, but Tamaki just shredded away my patience.

"Its not like my life has gotten any better since I was Forced to join the club! I'm constantly humiliated, Nobody takes me seriously, and my debts keep adding up to the point I want to kill myself!" I yell. I was finally venting my anger and I had no regrets. They all just stare in disbelief.

"I'm just a girl whose trying to make ends meet, and it seems that I'm going to be kicked out of my apartment because my bank account is always empty and when I do get money I either use it to buy food or pay off the club for my debts!" I yell and I start to calm down a bit.

"I'm not rich. I can't make my problems go away with money... when we go home, I hope you guys forget about me." I say as I walked away from the guys and headed down the beach to the hotel. No way in hell was I going to share the beach house that Honey Senpai had after that.

~~ Tamaki's pov ~~

"when we go home, I hope you guys forget about me." Haruhi said as she walked down the beach, presumably to the hotel.

Oh god... what have I done...

"Tama-San... you went too far." Honey senpai said.

"Honey's right, Tamaki. Haruhi didn't deserve that." Mori said I'm agreement with Honey.

"I... I didnt mean to-"

"she was right, though. If it wasn't for her, stalling for time, we never would have gotten to those girls in time, let alone even know that they were in danger." Kyoya replied in his solemn tone.

"Now she hates us. We wont see her at the school anymore..." the twins said in unison.

Everyone walked back to Honey's beach house. Honey was crying a little and mori tried his best to calm his little cousin.

This was all my fault. Haruhi's head was in the right place to help, it didnt matter if she was a boy or a girl, she was there and responded quickly without hesitation. Now she thinks it's her fault and she wants to leave the club because of me...

~~ Later, in the Hotel. Normal pov ~~

( Since the girls think that Haruhi is a boy, her pronouns change to "he, him" unless she is with the Host club )

Haruhi stayed in her room and just sulked in her own self pity. She thought that Tamaki cared about her. Guess not.

A few of the girls were confused why Haruhi was staying at the hotel instead of the beach house.

"Havent you heard?" One of the girls said

"Haruhi got in a pretty bad argument with Tamaki and now he wants to leave the Host Club." A few girls gasped at the news.

"But that's not fair! he tried to saved us from those trespassers when none of the other Members of the host club were even close enough to help!" One of the girls that was saved by the host club said out loud.

"Well, since Haruhi is weaker than the other Members, they got mad at him for trying."

The girls felt bad for Haruhi and went to his room to try and comfort him. They knocked on his door "Haruhi? Are you there? We... we just want to see if your okay." One of the girls said.

"Y-yeah. I'm fine..." Haruhi sounded upset.

"Haruhi, if you want any help, were always here if‐"

"No- no thanks. I'm alright." Haruhi interrupted, not sounding rude, just wanting to be alone. The girls sighed solemnly and left Haruhi alone.

As the girls left, a certain blonde walked up to them. "Excuse me, ladies. But do you know where Haruhi's room is?"

Oh of them sighed "Haven't you done enough, Tamaki?"

"W-what?" Tamaki was surprised a little.

"We heard what happened. Haruhi doesn't want to see anyone." They started to walk away again.

Tamaki took a girl by the hand and pleaded "please, I need to apologize..."

The girl stated for a moment at the lavendar eyed blonde. She sighed "he's in room 226."

Tamaki thanked the girl and ran to that room.

The end.

( Should I do a part 2? )