Ok, so first off, SPOILER WARNING!!!

Second, I am just gonna give my thoughts and feelings about Tigerhearts Shadows right here and now.

Ok, so first... It wasn't actually a bad book. I actually thought it was a great book!

The beginning upset me when the second sentence in the book was literally, I have to reach Dovewing! But they actually grew on me a little bit.

I don't completely ship it, but, I'm ok with them as a couple. I don't dislike them, but I don't love them.

I also really like Tigerheart as a character. Sure they kinda made him into a mary sue by making him right about Fog, and all that, but I enjoyed him. He gets a thumbs up from me!

And Dovewing... I'm ok with her now. She's actually a better mother than I thought she'd be, and she doesn't just care about herself in this book. She actually takes others feelings into account by just being on the sidelines.

And I personally am not a fan with the whole thing when Tigerheart was dying, and she told him not to sleep.

If a cat is in excruciating pain, or if anyone is in that kind of pain, you should let them rest! I understand you want to see them live, and be beside them with your kits Dovewing, but he was barely conscious the entire time while you made him walk.

But... this has to be one of my favorite parts... Dovewing and Tigerheart reminiscing about when they first started meeting up. I thought it was a really touching moment, and I'm sad that it ended as soon as it started.

I'm also glad that Spiresight made it to StarClan, and along with Spiresight, I really just love all the new characters they brought in. Sure we will... probably never see them again, but I loved them.

I'm also surprised that there was hardly any filler to this book... Even in the chapters where they were traveling, they kept the plot going, and brought cats in, and.... killed one off.... Rest in peace Spiresight..

And yeah, that's most of my thought on it. I actually really enjoyed this book way more than I thought I would! I hope there are more books like this and--

*whispers*

mmhmm. wha--. Wait... No... NOO!!!

THERE MAKING ANOTHER SUPER EDITION, AND ITS ABOUT FRICKEN CROWFEATHER!?!?!?

WHAT THE HECK, ERINS SLOW THE FRICK DOWN, JESUS!!!

(ha ha, get it, because the guardian cats lived in a church, ha haaaaa)