Jacob : Him, You guys were having a picnic and it kinda slipped out.

Millard : You, you saved him and thinking both of you would die you said it.

Horace : Him, he had a premonition about telling him he loved you, when it didn't come true he told you. You immediately saying you loved him too.

Enoch : Him. Someone started flirting it's you and he confronted you about it which ended in 'I love you'.