Amber Heard as Cassandra Moore (Y'all need to chill the f out. I cast Amber Heard at least 4 years ago because her appearance fit my vision of Cassandra Moore. I also don't keep up on celebrities' lives so if this was going on then, I had no idea. You can picture someone else if you want. Literally just chill the f out).

Jensen Ackles as Dean Winchester

Jared Padalecki as Sam Winchester

Misha Collins as Castiel

Jim Beaver as Bobby Singer

Mark Sheppard as Crowley

Kurt Fuller as Zachariah

Rob Benedict as Chuck Shurley

Matt Cohen as Michael

Ian Somerhalder as Michael (to Cassandra in 2009/2010)