Gun or knife or sword
Andrea: knife
Emma: gun
Katie: is "hugs" an answer?
Trinity: katanna/sword
Jocelyn: butcher knife
Me/Caitlyn: knights sword
(Other)Caitlin: do I have to answer?
Me/Caitlyn: yes! Cake or death!?!?
(Other)Caitlin: knife . . . cake.
Falicity: gun

P.s. Jeremiah is kicked out for 5 chapters. I KEEP MY WORD PEOPLE!