A/N: Couldn't sleep so decided to write another chapter. Thank you for the positive feedback. Which former Warblers would you like to see show up in the story? Do you think I should make it Sebastian vs Hunter for Rachel? Do you think Hunter and Rachel make a good pairing?

Disclaimer: I do not own Glee, characters or song lyrics.

**********************

Rachel sat in her office working on plans for New Directions with Kurt when there was a knock on the door.

??: Excuse me, Miss Berry?

Rachel: Yes, may I help you?

??: I'm new to McKinley and on the Football team. I saw the sign up sheet for New Directions and I'd love to audition.

Kurt: Can you sing? You kind of remind me of Finn and Sam mixed into one.

Rachel: We would love to hear you . What's your name?

??: My name is Spencer, ma'am.

Rachel: Please call me Rachel. Ma'am makes me sound ancient.

Spencer: Well, I was raised to respect . But, thank you Rachel.

Kurt: And, I am Kurt Hummel. Just out of curiosity, are you straight? Not that it matters.

Rachel: Kurt?! That's rude!

Spencer: As a matter of fact I am gay, and no one messes with me especially being a joke because I don't take crap from anyone.

Kurt: Wow, a mixture of Finn, Sam and Puck in one.

Rachel: Spencer, what song will you be singing?

Spencer: I will sing O Town's 'All or Nothing ' for you.

Rachel: I love that song. Go ahead, Spencer.

Spencer took a deep breath, and then he began. Once he sang the first few verses, Rachel and Kurt could not keep the smiles off their faces. Spencer sang right to Rachel.

(Spencer)

All Or Nothing"

I know when he's been on your mind
 That distant look is in your eyes
 I thought with time you'd realize it's over, over
 It's not the way I choose to live
 And something somewhere's gotta give
 As sharing in this relationship gets older, older

 You know I'd fight for you but how could I fight someone who isn't even there
 I've had the rest of you now I want the best of you I don't care if that's not fair

 Cuz I want it all
 Or nothing at all
 There's nowhere left to fall
 When you reach the bottom it's now or never
 Is it all
 Or are we just friends
 Is this how it ends
 With a simple telephone call
 You leave me here with nothing at all

 There are time it seems to me
 I'm sharing you with memories
 I feel it in my heart but I don't show it , show it
 Then there's times you look at me
 As though I'm all that you could see
 Those times I don't believe it's right I know it , know it

 Don't make me promises baby you never did know how to keep them well
 I had the rest of you now I want the best of you it's time to show and tell

 Cuz I want it all
 Or nothing at all
 There's nowhere left to fall
 When you reach the bottom it's now or never
 Is it all
 Or are we just friends
 Is this how it ends
 With a simple telephone call
 You leave me here with nothing at all

 Cuz you and I
 Could lose it all if you've got no more room
 No more inside for me in your life

 Cuz I want it all
 Or Nothing at all
 There's nowhere left to fall
 It's now or never

 Is it all
 Or Nothing at all
 When you reach the bottom it's now or never
 Is it all
 Or are we just friends
 Is this how it ends
 With a simple telephone call
 You leave me here with nothing at all
 There's nowhere left to fall

As soon as Spencer sang the last verse, Rachel and Kurt nodded. Spencer had the looks (blond hair, blue eyes, gorgeous), and a phenomenal voice with the potential of being a male lead.

Rachel: Wow, Spencer, you are Amazing!

Spencer: Thank you, so am I in?

Kurt: Well Spencer how can we put this nicely..

Spencer looked nervous.

Rachel: I just have one thing to say.

Spencer: And what's that?

Rachel: *smiling * Be here tomorrow after your last class. Welcome to the New Directions, Spencer!

Spencer: Thank you, Miss Berry. I mean, Rachel. I cant tell you how happy I am.

Kurt: We are happy to have you.We shall see you tomorrow.

Spencer shook Kurt's hand, and hugged Rachel. Then left the office on cloud nine.

Rachel: Well Kurt we are off to a good start.

Kurt: We still have a way to go, but we can do this..

Sue walked in and simply said: "This is war, Barbra and Porcelain. You have now entered the Thunder dome."

Rachel: Sue, you don't scare us at all. Please leave, we have work to do."

Sue: You will fail, just like your tv show and Broadway career.

Sue left, and Rachel looked down in tears.

Kurt: Don't listen to her, Rachel. She's just trying to mess with your confidence.

Rachel:I know..I'm just scared to fail again.

Kurt: You won't because you have so many behind you. Including me.

Rachel: How about we call it a day, and go home. We will continue tomorrow. Hopefully we can find more to audition. I believe that Marley, Ryder, Kitty, and Jake are returning. That's a plus.

Kurt: Well I've got to head home. I will see you tomorrow, my Diva. Love you.

Rachel: Love you too. *Hugs Kurt* I'll be leaving soon myself.

Just as Kurt left, Rachel was finishing paperwork and preparing to leave, when she heard footsteps behind her. Without looking up, she heard a voice come into the room.

??: Well well if it isn't Miss Broadway herself?

Rachel: I don't have time for this, Hunter.

??: Who said anything about Hunter? Geez pretty girl, you already forgot who I am?

Rachel frowned and looked up, and her eyes widened when she saw who it was...

Rachel: Sebastian?

Sebastian: Hello pretty girl, Welcome Back.

**************************

Meanwhile Hunter and the Warblers were rehearsing. A female named Jane wants to be a Warbler, but we shall see how that goes.

Blaine: Okay Warblers, let's try again from the top. Tighten up the choreography as well. Hunter I want you to sing lead along with Ian and Jon. (A/N: Ian and Jon are OC.)

 "Full Service"
(A/N: NKOTB feat. New Edition)

(Ian)

I see you pulling on up in your car
 And there's something on your mind
 You've been driving around the whole night
 Now you're pulling up next to mine

(Jon)
 I'll lift the hood and look up under
 From the front and to the bumper
 Roll the window up and lock the door
 Cause I'm gonna bring rain and thunder

(Hunter)

[Bridge:]
 I'll fill you up-up (If you wanna get some)
 I'll pump you up-up (Cause I got the premium)
 I'll fill you up-up, pump you up-up
 'Till the tip-top, drip drop, don't stop, don't stop

(Warblers)

[Chorus:]
 You ain't gotta do it yourself, baby
 I'm-a give you that full service, you'll see
 You ain't gotta, gotta be nervous, nervous
 I'm-a give you, give you full service, service...

(Hunter)
 You ain't even gotta get out of your seat
 I'm-a give you that full service, you'll see
 You ain't gotta, gotta be nervous, nervous
 I'm-a give you, give you full service, service...

(Blaine)

 I see you pulling up to the bar
 And there's something on your mind
 Like you've been hanging around the whole night,
 Just sittin' there sippin' up on your wine
 I'll pop the cork and fill the glasses
 I'll wipe it up if your drink splashes
 Send the check my way tonight,
 Tonight you don't pay, cause I wanna protect your assets

(Hunter)

[Bridge]

(Warblers)

[Chorus]

(Hunter)

 If you could only see, how good it could be
 Anything you need, I'm-a step right up
 And it's on me, ain't no doubt I'm-a work it on out
 If you could only see, how good it could be
 Anything you need, I'm-a step right up
 And it's on me, ain't no doubt I'm-a work it on out

(Warblers)

[Chorus 2x]

Blaine: Great job guys! Done for the day!

Hunter: So Anderson, who's Captain?

Blaine: Undecided at the moment. I'm not sure if you would be a wise choice at the moment.

Hunter: What happened to second chances?

Blaine: That is something that is earned. We have a long way to go to showing everyone the Warblers are back and legit. I don't want anymore drama or scandals.

. Hunter: How can I earn it, when you won't give me that chance?

Blaine: How do I know you can be trusted? We will see. For now just be content to being a Warbler again, and a lead. I want all of you to have an opportunity to shine.

Hunter: You have been around Rachel WAY too long.

Blaine: Well, she IS my best friend and one of the most talented I know.

Hunter: She failed, though.

Blaine: Despite that, Rachel STILL was the Star on Broadway in an iconic role such as Fanny. I'm proud of her.

??: So are we. And welcome back buddy. Back in Warbler colors.

Blaine: Jeff! Nick! Trent! My boys!

Blaine quickly ran over to hug his friends.

Nick: Welcome back, Mr. New York !

Jeff: Where is Kurt?

Blaine: He is with Rachel at McKinley. We have put our engagement temporarily on hold.

Trent: Sorry about that. Speaking of Rachel, I got to see her on Broadway. Too bad it didn't work out, but she was still amazing.

Blaine: Yeah she is. Who else is back?

Thad: I believe Sebastian texted me and said he went to surprise Rachel.

" Rachel? What the hell? Damn you Sebastian...she is Mine. " Hunter thought to self.

*******************************

Rachel: OMG Sebastian? What are you doing here?

Sebastian: Well myself and some of the former Warblers are visiting and I thought I'd visit Broadway's Darling.

Rachel: Are you here to make fun of me?

Sebastian: Actually no, I got a chance to see you in New York and I am quite proud of you. Out of everyone in New Directions, I knew you would make it. And wish you the best of luck with reviving the Glee club.

Rachel: Wow, when did you become so nice?

Sebastian: I was always nice, it just depended on who you were. Plus, I am just as competitive as you are.

Rachel: Well, thank you. What are you doing HERE though? I've had enough of Warblers this week.

Sebastian: Who?

Rachel: Hunter has been pursuing me.

Sebastian: Hunter huh? Hmm..so are you saying I may have competition?

Rachel: Excuse me?

Sebastian: Never mind. You know it's been awhile since I've heard you sing. And I've always wanted to duet with you. It would be epic.

Rachel: You know what? To be honest, I've wanted to duet with you too.

Sebastian: What do you say? *Sebastian walked over to piano*

"All We'd Ever Need" (A/N: By Lady Antebellum)

(Rachel)
Boy it's been all this time
 And I can't get you off my mind
 And nobody knows it but me

 I stare at your photograph
 Still sleep in the shirt you left
 And nobody knows it but me

 Everyday I wipe my tears away
 So many nights I've prayed for you to say

[Chorus] (Rachel)
 I should've been chasing you
 I should've been trying to prove
 That you were all that mattered to me

(Sebastian)
 I should've said all the things that I kept inside of me
 And maybe I could've made you believe
 That what we had was all we'd ever need

(Sebastian)

 My friends think I'm moving on
 But the truth is I'm not that strong
 And nobody knows it but me

 And I've kept all the words you said
 In a box underneath my bed
 And nobody knows it but me

 But if you're happy I'll get through somehow
 But the truth is that I've been screaming out

(Both)

[Repeat Chorus]

 I should've been chasing you
 You should've been trying to prove
 That you were all that mattered to me

(Rachel)
 Oh you should've said all the things
 That I kept inside of me
 And maybe you could've made me believe

(Sebastian)
 That what we had girl
 Oh that what we had, what we had
 It was all we'd ever need

(Rachel)
 It was all we'd ever need

Sebastian: Wow..amazing. How come we didn't so that a long time ago?

Rachel: I don't know. Bad timing? Plus the whole nearly blinding Blaine and blackmailing me..

Sebastian: I am sorry for the mistakes I've made. And I am sorry about Finn. True we weren't friends at all, but he was a good man. I know he meant a lot to you.

Rachel: You're forgiven Sebastian. And thank you.

Sebastian: So you and Hunter?

Rachel: There's nothing between us, I barely know him.

Sebastian: If there is nothing, would you be opposed to maybe going out with me? For old times sake?

Rachel: I'll think about it. You still have my number?

Sebastian: Not since you moved.

Rachel grabbed a post-it writing her number and email down.

Rachel: Here, don't be a stranger.

Sebastian: I'll call you soon, Pretty girl.

Rachel gave him a hug. Who would've thought she would be hugging Sebastian Smythe? And what about Hunter? And why is she thinking of guys, period.

Sebastian: I'd better go. * kissing her forehead*

Rachel blushed. Her heartbeat fast. She never really noticed how good looking Sebastian was, but so was Hunter. Dalton certainly knew how to groom their men that's for sure..

Rachel gathered her things and headed home. She received a text.

Hunter: Hello beautiful Rachel..so you and Sebastian? I still don't give up. You know you still can't resist me.

Rachel: Can't you take no for an answer?

Hunter: Just keep lying to yourself, Rachel. One day you will want me and say yes.

Rachel sighed and threw her phone in her purse. Last thing she needs is men drama!

*****************

A/N: Hope you enjoyed!! Read & Review xoxo