Due to votes, story will be in 2nd person from here on out

It was pretty late in the night, and you were in BEN's room watching him play video games. You had snuck in there quietly without him noticing at first, and sat on his bed to watch him, bored since most of everyone else had either gone to bed or went out to kill.

He noticed you when he had just finished winning a round of Mortal Kombat and you accidentally cheered out loud, giving him a slight scare.

"Okay, I'm not complaining or anything, but what are you doing in my room?" BEN asked, turning to glare at you. "I'm bored, and I have nothing else to do," You sighed, resting your chin on the palm of your hand and looking back at BEN lazily.

"Cool. Nice of you to want to come hang with me," He said with a grin, and stood from his place on the floor to sit beside you. "I've only come to watch you play, that's it," You grumbled, narrowing your eyes at him. "Fine by me," BEN shrugged his shoulders and began to play again.

You continued to watch him play for a while, then you started to get bored again and trailed off into your own thoughts. You thought about everyone in the mansion and how much time that had already passed of you living here. You remembered how scared you were in the beginning, and how you thought everyone was going to hate you.

You snickered to yourself and sighed happily, aware of how much you had grown and been through. "Hey BEN," you spoke, catching the pasta's attention, "remember when I first came here? To the mansion?"

"Yeah I remember, you were scared like a lost puppy but it was cute as hell," He replied, casting you a quick glance. You rolled your eyes and thought again, of the time not very long ago. "Hey, you had a life before the mansion, of course. What was it like before you came here?" BEN asked, and for the first time in a very long time, you thought back to your life before being a Creepypasta.

You thought about your parents...about your old home, about your old way of life. How it all suddenly came to an end by a simple visit from the Slenderman.

"It was...alright. Pretty normal, I guess, until Slender showed up that one night," You replied, looking aways as you collected your memories. "What, did he kill off your folks or something?"

"No...they were specifically gone that night, and Slender came when I was all alone."

"Just like that? I wonder how your parents must have reacted when they came back and saw you gone."

You slowly nodded, beginning to wonder the same thing. How did your parents react to your disappearance? It was a long time since you had seen them, and you were just now beginning to reflect on your memories with them.

"I bet they were probably glad they fond me gone. I was an annoying child, anyways," You remarked, shrugging your shoulders. "Aww, really?" BEN snickered, and rested his game controller on his head. "You wouldn't know that (Y/N), it's not like you ever went back to see them."

"Come on BEN, you know Slender wouldn't allow that..."

"Yeah he would! But only if yur gonna kill them after finding them. Slender says if your paying a visit to old family n' stuff, you've gotta pay the price by killing them off or bringing them to him in the woods."

Kill...my...parents??

"I couldn't," You said, shaking your head. "I could never bring myself to kill my own parents."

"Yeah you can," BEN said, eyeing you with a smirk. "You're a killer, aren't ya? If you're truly one of us, you could kill anyone without a problem. Even your own parents..."

You looked down in thought, wondering if going out to see your parents again would really be worth it. After all, it would only unfortunately end in you having to kill them, and then you could only get imagine the remorse you would feel.

But in the end, did it really matter? You had a new family now, a new life. They were a part of your past, and that was where your back was turned to. You were a killer, and your job now was to murder under Slenderman's command.

"I really do want to see them again," You said, casting your glance at BEN, "and I'm willing to risk their life to see them again. It won't be too bad."

"Want me to come with you?" BEN asked, "can I, (Y/N)?"

"Sure BEN, why not. I think I'll need the company there, anyways. Things might get awkward with seeing them again after so long."

"right," BEN said, and he hopped off from his bed to turn off the game. "I'm ready whenever you are. Make sure you tell Slenderman where we're going."

You nodded and slid off of his bed, heading for the door. You couldn't believe that you were actually going to see your parents again after so long. You were nervous and curious as to how they would react once they see you again.

At the same time, you was extremely tense about having to kill them afterwards. They had never done you wrong; they were average normal, caring parents. They were never abusive towards you, nor did they ever show any acts of abuse towards you. Killing them just didn't seem fair, but you didn't really have a choice.

"BEN, let's go!" You called out, and the creepy link quickly sprung behind you in obedience. BEN took out his phone from his shirt and smirked, swiping away at the screen, "I'm going to be taking pictures of this..."

He then looked up at you and chuckled nervously, "Wh-What's with that face? I'm only gonna do it for memories, heheh!"

"Why do you need to take pictures of my family?"

"Come on (Y/N), it's getting late and I want to get back and finish off my game," BEN whined, and you sighed, heading out of his room. You first ran to your room to get your brand new (W/T)! You no longer had to use a knife anymore, Slenderman finally gave you your own desired weapon and it was like your trademark now. After getting your weapon, you and BEN head down the stairs for Slenderman's hall.

Once you both got there, you led way into Slender's office, where he was still organizing papers as usual. "(Y/N)? BEN? What brings you two here?"

"I want to head out to see my parents, if you don't mind," You spoke, walking up to his desk and looking down at his papers. "BEN will come with me, and I promise I'll carry the responsibility of killing them afterwards."

"I see," Slenderman said, placing a pen on one of the stacks and facing you. "Are you sure this is something you want to do?"

"Yeah, boss. Is it alright with you?"

"That's fine with me, but make sure you do your duty afterwards, and make sure BEN stays out of trouble."

"What makes you think I'm gonna try and get into trouble?" BEN scowled, crossing his arms. "You're already a handful here, I'm just waiting to hear how you screw things up for my proxy out there," Slenderman sighed in reply.

"Aw Yeah? I'll show you, Slender-butt. Come on (Y/N), let's get outta here," BEN hissed, pulling your arm and heading out the office. You whisper-yell a "Thank you!" out at Slender before turning to follow with BEN.

••• timeskip•••

You and BEN were nearing the old neighborhood which you had used to live in. You were scolding BEN because of how slow he was walking behind; he was trying to play on his phone at the same time.

"BEN, we're getting close to my home. Please, put that away," You mumble, casting him a back glance. "Right right, just let me get through this last level-"

"Put it away or I take it!"

BEN groaned in annoyance and slowly shut off his phone, putting it away. You sigh as he jogs to catch up with you, and then the two of you head towards a pleasant looking house at the beginning of the street. Memories come flooding quickly back to you as you look at the house, and the you remember the memories of being at home.

"(Y/N)? You're slowing down. Getting nervous?" BEN asked, shaking your arm. "I'm good," You faintly reply, and pick up the pace as you both enter the driveway. Together, you both step up to the front door, and you only stand there, staring at it for a while.

"Sure, take your time. We can even stand here till tomorrow evening, if you want," BEN scoffed, and you grumble beneath your breath, "Just keep your mouth shut, elf."

You raise your finger and press the doorbell, your anxiety rising as you hear the ding from inside the house and wait to hear the sound of your parents approaching the door.

"You think they'd be up at this time?"

"I'm sure. I've seen them up at later times anyways."

"What were they doing up so late, hm~?"

"BEN!"

"Ben Who?"

The voice that came from inside made your heart skip a beat and your quickly turn, facing the door as it slowly opened.

You see the face of your mother come into view, and you stare in complete silence, lost for any words you could have said. She stared back at you, her hands slowly being brought up to her mouth and tears welling up in her eyes.

"(Y/N)..! (Y/N), (Y/N), (Y/N)!!!"

"Y-Yeah...hey mom..." You reply, your voice shaky and excited at the same time. Your mother looked to be on the verge of a breakdown, so you quickly step forwards and wrap your arms around her, feeling her warm embrace again, just like the old days! She cried in your arms; you felt her tears wet you sleeves, and you smiled.

"I'm so happy to see you again, (Y/N)...!"

"I'm happy to see you too, mom."

After some time of the emotional reunion, your mother finally pulled away and sighed, wiping her tears. "Where have you been? Oh god (Y/N), Where have you been, and what happened? It was all too much..."

"I'm sorry for scaring you mom," You say, but you stop there and refrained from continuing on. For some reason, you were completely lost, and had no idea what you should say to her. Had it really been that long? No....?

"I'm just so overwhelmed right now...wh-whose this little boy with you?" Your mother asked, and you turn and smirk at BEN.

"Excuse me, but I'm fucking sixteen years old, I'm nearly a man," BEN growled, crossing his arms, and you widen your eyes at him for his reply. "BEN!"

"O-Oh I'm sorry then...were you perhaps the one that found my precious little (Y/N)?"

"Mom...."

"...You can say that! Why else would I be here with her now?" BEN said with a smirk, and you quickly cup your hand over his mouth. "Stop talking."

"She's also my girlfriend!" BEN joked.

"Just Stop Talking!" You hiss at him, and press your hand over his mouth to the point all he said was muffled mess.

Your mother was all over the place at the moment, so overwhelmed by your return that she wasn't really paying attention to some things. She cringed a bit, looking at BEN's facial features and his hands and murmured, "Wh-What's wrong with your eyes? Why do they look like that....and your fingers are so sharp..."

"It's cosplay, mom," You cut in, "he's just dressing up for fun, a creepy version of Link from Legends Of Zelda. He really pulled it off, don't you think?"

"Yeah Yeah.....very...nice. I'm going to go get your father," She replied, and she gave an awkward smile before quickly turning and heading up the stairs.

You sigh and remove your hand from BEN's mouth, then you glare at him. "What?" BEN snarked, and you slowly rub your forehead in frustration. "Can you please quit acting like an idiot in front of my mom? She's very strict about the type of people I hang around."

"It doesn't matter, she'll be dead before we're gone~"

You feel a knot grow in your throat, and you think about having to kill your parents once you and BEN decide to leave. This was going to be much harder than you thought.

"Got anything to eat?" BEN asked, heading in the direction of where your kitchen was. "I don't know BEN, I haven't been here in ages. We can take a look if you want."

The two of you head to the kitchen and you open up the pantry to see what there was. Unfortunately, there was nothing there that you or BEN were interested in snagging. "Veggie Chips, really? Your parents are lame."

"They used to buy the good stuff, trust me."

"Maybe they stopped since you were gone."

You nod and turn when you hear footsteps running down the stairs, and you see your father quickly come into sight. "Where (Y/N)?!"

"In here, Dad," You say, waving from the kitchen, and he froze, his face slowly widening into a smile. "(Y/N)!!!"

He ran over to you and quickly picked you up in his arms, crushing you in a hug. "I can't believe it's you! I can't believe it's really you!"

"I-I know-Ergh-"

He noticed that he was squeezing you too much and gently put you back down, running a hand through his hair and giving a laugh, "You've come back to us! This is just....what can I say? I'm so overjoyed!"

"I'm so happy to see you too Dad. Both of you."

Your mother came from behind your father and rested a hand on his shoulder, giving you a quickly glance and then whispering something in his ear. He nodded a bit and looked over in BEN's direction, his smile slowly fading. "(Y/N)...whose that?"

"This is my friend, BEN."

"I'm pretty sure we're more than friends at this point."

"BEN so help me..."

"So BEN..." Your father spoke up, stepping up closer to the pasta, "do you happen to know anything about why or how our little girl disappeared, hm?"

"Why? Are you suggesting I kidnapped her or something?" BEN growled, "because I totally would, but in this case, I did not."

"Oh really," Your father scoffed, "well if you say you didn't, then I'll keep your word on that. I assume you're the one that brought her here after presumably finding her, and I thank you for that. But now, I will have to please ask you to leave."

"What, WHAT?"

You look at BEN who was now giving an angry snarl at your father. "I'm telling ya, I'm not the cause behind her disappearance, alright? You heard what she said, I'm her 'friend'!"

"Yes and I understand that, but we would like some time alone with our child if you don't mind..."

"Hey guys it's alright, BEN can stay..." You try cutting in, but your father holds up his palm to you. "(Y/N), stay out of this. "BEN", please leave."

BEN looked over at you and shifted his head in a way, clenching his teeth, like he was trying to tell you 'Can we just kill them off now?'

You quickly glance away from him to your parents, and see a hint of fear in their eyes as they looked at BEN. "You guys aren't scared of him, are you?" You ask, narrowing your eyes, "he's just wearing makeup and a costume, come on!"

"Yes yes, and it's very very nice," Your mother said with a shakily voice. "It's no use, (Y/N)," BEN mumbled, crossing his arms, and you glare at him, "What do you mean?"

"It's no use trying to hide me from them. Your mother already saw me glitch out a bit."

What? When?

"I-I-I didn't see you do such a thing," You stammer, trying to keep up the act, but BEN shook his head. "(Y/N), they ready saw me do it. There's no shame in hiding it now..."

BEN then smirked and held up his arm towards your parents. He made his whole arm dissolve into raw script and coding, and then he quickly changed it back. Both of your parents stepped back and their faces turned into disturbed expressions.

"Wh-Whatever you are...." Your mother shuttered, "Get...Out..."

"Alright, I'll leave," BEN snickered with a shrug, "but (Y/N)'s gonna have to come with me~"

"Oh you leave our daughter alone and just get out!" Your father shouted, reaching aside to the kitchen counter for a knife that was sitting aside.

"Nope. I can't allow you to harm BEN at all," You snap, quickly stepping in front of BEN protectively. "I'm sorry guys..."

"Why are you defending that...that....that freak!" Your mother shrieked, tightly holding on to your father's arm.

"He's not a freak!" You shout back, your hands shaking, and you feel BEN lightly grab you arm which calms you down a bit. "He's not a freak...he's family to me. I can't allow anyone to harm him. He means too much to me."

"He's no family of ours," Your father growled. "Yes, no family of yours," You sneer back, "But he is family that's mine."

"Come on, (Y/N)," BEN chuckled, "do the job and take 'em out now."

"T-Take then out? What does he mean, (Y/N)?" Your mother asked, looking at you with wide eyes. You sigh and clench your fist, trying not to let any tears slip loose from your eyes. "It means....I have to.....to....."

Your voice fades off as you slowly begin to take out your (W/T) and hold it out in front of you, making both of your parents gasp and back away from you.

"(Y-Y/N)....What's....What's this about!? Did that sadistic...elf boy make you like this?"

"No..." You say, your voice shaking, "someone much worse made me like this...and I wouldn't change for anything."

BEN grinned widely, and a maniacal laugh suddenly erupted from his mouth, making your parents shutter in fear. Your father stepped a bit towards you, the knife still in hand, "I'm sorry you've become like this....but I can't a-allow you to h-hurt anyone...I can't allow you to hurt us, your parents," He said, his voice drowned in sorrow as he stepped closer and closer towards you with the knife.

"I'm so sorry, for your sake, that I've become like this," You reply, stepping towards him with your weapon, "but in truth, I have no regrets that I'm like this."

The Creepypasta in you suddenly kicks in, and you dash at your father, lunging your weapon into his stomach and twisting it to shear his insides with the blade. [If you use Ranged, you shot him a few times.]

His screams, along with your mothers combined were torture to your ears, yet at the same time they were wonderfully musical. A dark smirk appears on your face, and pull your weapon from his stomach, then inserting it into his chest and diving it straight through his heart. His eyes rolled back and he stumbled onto the ground, his body completely limp upon impact. "Life's unfair, isn't it," You sigh, looking down at his face imprinted with shock.

You turn quickly when your see your mother turn and dart for the steps, screaming her head off and you stand. "I've got this, (Y/N)!" BEN exclaimed, and he quickly disappeared before you could retort. "Wh-, BEJAMINNNN!!!"

Your mother ran in a frenzy for her room, only to suddenly see blue lights and a figure slowly materializing in front of her, forming the image of the strange boy that her daughter was with.

"You can't run, you can't hide...." The boy snickered, slowly shaking his head. He then tilted his head to a perfect 90 degree angle and grinned evilly at her. "Ah, you've met with a terrible fate, haven't you?"

Before she could react, the boy pixelated his hand and stuck it right through her body; his arm then turned back to its normal form and she screamed out in pure agony.

You dart up the stairs just in time to see BEN's arm sticking right through your mother's torso. He saw you and quickly ripped his arm out, pulling out some of her insides and making blood spurt out from the wound and onto his hands and on the ground.

The woman gagged and fell to the ground, clutching the area she was attacked. You slowly walk up to her, seeing that her eyes were still open and that she was barely hanging onto life. She looked up at you with tears and feelings of betrayal in her eyes, and coughed up some blood onto the floor. "Mom..." You say, your voice surprisingly calm, yet it slightly hurt you.

"I.............I still l-love you.......(Y/N)......I always.........w-will........."

You slowly nod to this and a tear slips from your eye, you could hold it no longer. You quickly raise the weapon and slit her throat, ending her life for good. "Life's unfair...isn't it...?" You sigh, examining her unmoving corpse. You feel arms wrap around you, and you look down to see BEN hugging you.

"Are you ok.....?"

"Yeah BEN, I'm fine. Just doing my job."

You smile a bit at him and pat his head, and he hugs you tighter, smiling back. "Let's go home now, okay?"

"Alright BEN. Let's go home."

• / ~~ / •

"So, everything went well? I can presume so by all the blood on both of your clothes."

You nod at Slenderman and grin, beginning feel proud of what you done, besides remorse. BEN boredly played on his phone beside you, and you playfully ruffle his pale blonde hair. "BEN was a great help, by the way. He didn't cause any problems for me," You add, and he looks up at you and smiles.

"That's good to hear," Slenderman replied, "I'm sorry for thinking negatively of you, BEN. I'm glad you were able to be of some help to my proxy."

"Told ya, Slender-butt," BEN snickered, and Slenderman's face formed a crease of a frown. "Yes, I am happy with you and all, but that gives you no right to be so rude! Watch your mouth, BEN."

"Come on BEN," You say, pulling him aside, "you wanna go play some video games together?"

"Hell yeah! Video games at 2 in the morning? I'm all up for it!"

"Both of you, bed, now," Slenderman ordered strictly, and the both of you groaned in annoyance, "Fineeee...."

The two of you head upstairs together, and you bid BEN a goodnight before starting to head to your room. "Hey (Y/N), wait," BEN stopped you, and you turn to look at him, "Yeah BEN?"

"Wanna go one round of Mario Kart before we head in?"

You smirked and nodded your head, beginning to walk in his direction. "Sure BEN, let's do it."

You felt quite better off, despite the fact you had murdered both of your parents. Even though they were no longer around, you had the Creepypastas there for you, and they were just about the best family you could ever ask for.