"You look gorgeous doll!" Your best friend (b/f/n) squeals when they see how amazing you look in your outfit for the date you're about to have in an hour.

"Thanks love. You sure this isn't too much?" You ask, trying very hard not to overdo anything. This was your first date!

"Don't worry! He's gonna pounce on you when he sees you" (b/f/n) says as they wink at you and finish with applying light makeup to your face. You blush at the thought of the date ever even going that far with.

You were our at a bookstore reading a new manga coming out when you bumped right into the guy, Sam Winchester . He saw the book you got so lost in before the collision, started to make conversation with you about books in general and asked if he could take you on a date after exchanging numbers.
Your whole life you've never had a guy, especially ones that look like him ask you on a date before so you didn't know why you even said yes in the first place.

It could be some kind of bet, he did have some other guy with him when he was in the bookstore.

Nah he could be just a sweet guy

Or a douche with a rap sheet a mile long and he wanted to add you to that list.

Shut up inner conscious!

You've been fighting your inner self so long you didn't even notice the bell rang, too late to back out now you straightened your choice of clothes and went to the front door.

As you got closer to the door you saw him, he is wearing a dark blue flannel with the sleeves rolled up above his elbows and dark blue denim jeans. His medium length hair is combed behind his ears a bit but some sticking out, his hazel eyes appeared to shine when he saw you..or must've been your imagination. He smiled at you as you walk towards him holding a single (f/c) rose.

His hair is so cute, I wonder how it would feel if I ran my fingers through..

Ooh no inner conscious. You put that dirty fantasy to the back cause the date hasn't even started yet!

You blush as your fantasy of him kissing you, making love to you started popping up like in the mangas you read. Only you just met the guy yesterday and this is no book, guys like him don't go for girls like you.

"Hey (y/n) you look..beautiful" he says clearing his throat as if he's nervous. You blush at the comment.

He didn't mean it like that.. you thought to yourself.

"Thanks, you do too" blushing harder realizing you basically said he was beautiful.

"UM I mean you look g-great I mean not that you aren't beautiful I just mean tha-"

"It's okay (y/n), shall we?" He chuckles then stretches his arm out to you to lead you out. You smile taking his arm, say goodbye to your best friend and head towards his car. He opens the door for you first then slides into the driver seat after. After a while of silence in the car as sam drove, you spoke.

"So..um where are we going?" You ask fiddling with your clothes.

"Well I figured since we just met we could see a movie at the drive thru" a sharp feeling pierced your heart when you heard that for some reason. Did he not want to be seen with you in public?

Told you he didn't like you for you

Shut up..

Noticing your silence, Sam continues.

"that way we can have much more to talk and never have the date end" he replied smiling as he blushes. He made you blush as well.

As you head to the drive thru you went to go see (movie choice). You decided you wanted to go get some popcorn with sam before it started. Some thin pretty girls near the soda stand were eye balling sam and laughing when they saw you.

"I can't believe that elephant got to land a smoking hot man like him. Must've been some bet he made and she fell for it"

Her words stung your heart because you had something similar to that happen last time. A guy you liked for two years in middle school had asked you to be his girlfriend in pe but once you asked why he liked you, he straight up told you he only did that because it was a dare. You've been broken ever since.

Sam notices you being quiet and saw the girls laughing at you. He decided to interlace your hand in his pulling you close and gently kissing your cheek, staying there for a while until the girls sneered and walked off. After he pulls away he looks down at you and you are blushing but also shocked at his actions.

"S-sorry.." he said looking down after grabbing the popcorn. You didn't want to overthink it so you brushed it off.

"N-no it's okay..Thank you." You smiled shyly taking hold of the drinks in hand and headed together back to the car.

As the movie started you were so into watching the movie that you didn't notice sam staring at you. He thought you were the most beautiful woman he has ever met, despite his lifestyle he has never met anyone quite like you. He wants to be a gentleman but yet the moment he saw you something animalistic started to brew inside him. It wasn't in a piece of meat sort of way but in something more than that.. he thought of the way you lips would feel against his the way your hand would feel tugging on his hair as he displayed kisses all over your body to show you that you were special. He wanted to show you that but he didn't want to scare you away on the first date.

Feeling some stares you turned your head as you are opening a box of pocky to eat. You notice sam staring and you notice a look you've never seen anyone give you before. A look of admiration as if he was looking at his favorite art in a museum. Ones that look just like everyone else's work but yet the one he's looking at looks unique and beautiful.

As you place a piece of pocky in your mouth, sam decides to try something. He leans in slowly and bites the other end of the pocky. You're blushing but you don't stop him, wondering what he planned on doing. He continues to slowly bite closer towards your lips as he stares into your (e/c) eyes. You decide to be brave and bite back, slowly but surely incase this goes downhill.  You continue until you are so close to each others lips (with the snack still in both of your mouths)that you can feel each other's breath stopping there. You assume he didn't want to kiss you anymore but just before you pull away he finished the snack and kisses you. It starts off slow and sincere as if you were gonna push him away but you didn't want to. Instead you kissed him back, putting your hand in his hair as you grip his scalp gently but demanding. He groans against your mouth and inserts his tongue, which surprises you since you've never French kissed before. Noticing your tension at his actions he pulls away slowly and notices your lips parted and your face the shade of a sunburn and tomato mixed, and he thought it was absolutely adorable.

"I-I'm so sorry I didn't mean to scare you I just-" but before he could finish you pulled him by his flannel and kissed him.

Wow you're making it so much easier for him to trick you into bed

Shut up! He's not like that

Or is he?

You decided to block out that evil voice in the back of your mind as you and sam have your heated makeout session as the movie continued. Your kisses were so heated, your car looked like the car scene from titanic. Once the movie was over sam decided to take you to a little diner where you can dance and eat. As you enter the diner you couldn't help but notice the stares again as they saw sam open the door for you and intertwine his hands with yours again. Whispers and snickers were heard all over the place that the dance music couldn't drown out, sam didn't seem to notice at all his eyes were only ever on you. As you took your seats in a booth sam reached for your hand and gently squeezed.

"I'm having a really fun time tonight" he says as he smiles at you rubbing your knuckles in his.

"I-I-I am as well" you blush looking down.

Your food arrives and after a while of talking, laughing and eating your doubts and the stares along with the snickers we're dissipating from your mind. You really felt something for him despite everything and you didn't want the night to end. Suddenly a song plays "little things by one direction" and you smile as you bob your head slowly to the rhythm, sam smiles noticing your love for the song. It reminded you of your past fantasies of your crushes asking you to prom dancing to this song..but it never happened. Sam has an idea and jumps up out of the booth.

"Would you like to dance?" Sam asks smiling as he's leaning over while holding out his hand.

Almost like in the movies and mangas..

You smile and take his hand as he leads you to the floor and you place one hand on his shoulder the other in his strong calloused hand. Sam has his hand around  around your waist and the other holding your soft but a bit rough hand. Listening to the lyrics he noticed the song sounds like you and him right now.

Your hand fits in mind like it's made just for me

Well bare this in mind it was meant to be

As the song continues, sam and you are slowly dancing as you're holding one another. The lyrics really felt to you as if you were meant to be in some strange way. It felt almost as if with sam you were invincible and you didn't want the night to end.

***But that all dies down when You hear the snickers and comments but you didn't know that Sam had as well.

"Look at them, he must be thinking someone save me from this nightmare" a guy with his group of friends say to eachother pointing at you. Sam couldn't take it anymore and gently pulled you aside and confronted the man by punching his face in. The man landed on the floor with a bloody lip.

"She is no nightmare! She is a dream and one that I'd like to have! So leave her alone. You're just mad you don't have a dream like her to hold"

You blushed so hard, mouth landing on the floor at his words. You wanted to believe you were a dream to him..

You are a total nightmare, he's just saying that to be nice then once he's done you'll be all alone again

This time you started to believe that evil voice in your mind and started to head towards the door when you heard sam calling your name. He chased after you, he got a hold of your hand and pulled you into your chest as his other hand cradled your cheek. Tears are almost spilling out of your eyes but you hoped he didn't notice.

"Hey what's wrong?"

"Nothing, I just wanted to have some fresh air" you lied.

"Well we can head back to your place if you'd like, I'd like to spend more time with you..if that's alright"

You were dumbfounded that he even wanted to continue the date after this. But you wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt so you nodded. Sam was relieved you didn't say no, he really wanted to makeup for what that guy said about you. You really were a dream, a dream he's always wanted to couldn't have with the lifestyle he has. He plans on keeping you though, there's something about you he can't quite figure out but he would like to try with as many dates as you would let him.

When you arrived to your one story house, sam was nice enough to open your door for you yet again. As you walked to your front door you stopped. Thinking back to all the things your evil voice said throughout the whole date, what if it's even true? What if this is a bet or just a conquest for him? A guy like him doesn't find you a dream..

"Hey what's wrong?" Sam asks pulling you out of your battle with your heart and mind. You close your mouth tightly, take a breath and turn to him to ask outright.

"Am I a bet to you?"

He chuckled figuring you were joking, can't you tell he finds your beautiful? But when you didn't laugh his chuckle died and he cleared his throat.

"No" he answered truthfully but you didn't believe it.

"Then why did you ask me out?"

"Isn't it obvious?"

Pause

"It's because I find your..everything about you to be amazing (y/n)"

"Nice try but I know a guy like you can't find this-" you say pointing to your body.

"To be..amazing or even a dream."

Sam decided to show you that chivalry isn't dead and remains a gentleman so he tells you exactly what he was doing.

"I was doing everything I did today to show you that I'm not just into you for sex..I like you for you. I respect you and your body, chivalry isn't around much anymore so I wanted to prove to you I find you worth the wait" Sam tells you. Assuming you just asked because you thought he wanted to have sex when you got to your house.

You were shocked that he was opening the doors for you and holding your hand to prove to you he wasn't seeing you as some object But as a person.

He's lying.

No he's not..

It's just a line to get into your pants.

That evil voice in your mind won.

"I'm sorry, but I'm not some easy lay that falls for every line you pull out of a song lyric. I had a great time, goodnight Sam"

You say as you hurriedly rush into your house and lock the door. You hear sam knocking and asking for your to let him prove it to you but you wouldn't let yourself be hurt..not again. You got many texts from sam later in the night asking to let him prove his attraction to you but you just turned your phone off and went to bed. Thinking about the way sam's lips felt on your head, his hands in yours, his smile, his laugh, everything made your heart flutter but you can't let history repeat. No matter what.

—————————-
Authors note:
I will make a part two if people like this part. Please don't hate I know I'm not good at writing but I tried. I haven't seen the show much since I was a kid so sorry if I got anything wrong. Thank you for reading!

-classic1985