a/n: I don't know how or why but the picture of olivia supposedly kissing benny is from the original version of this chapter. I updated and republished it a couple of days ago and I can't get rid of the kissing picture, so just ignore that 😂

"How'd your little speech go?" Olivia asked Ethan, as her and Rory walked up towards them. She wondered why Benny wasn't there, but didn't ask.

"Yeah, can I use my Mii as my yearbook profile?" Rory eagerly asked.
Olivia chuckled. He was such a nerd.

"Sorry, Rory, maybe next year?"
"Come on?! You want me to take them out? Maybe eat their families?" Rory suggested. Olivia shot him a glare.

"Rory?!" Ethan hissed.
He laughed. "I'm just kidding! You looked all, oh no! Rory's a manic!" He sighed. "That was great."

"Don't joke about that, okay?" Olivia said, seriously.
"Sometimes I wonder what you do at night..." Ethan remarked.

"Oh, it's pretty nuts. The less you know the better." Rory said, thinking about last night where he tried to fit as marshmallows in his mouth as possible whilst watching TV. He grinned when he remembered the number 4069; his new personal record.

"Anyway," He carried on. "What do the yearbook nerds wanna do?"

"Hannah Price wants to use some lame old camera for the photos. She probably doesn't even know she has to develop the old photos. She's probably standing there right now wondering why the screen isn't working." He laughed. Olivia glared at him. "She's right behind me, isn't she?"

"See ya!" Olivia said, Rory followed. "Where are we going?" Rory asked her. "I don't know about you, but I'm looking for Benny."

Olivia saw Benny walking into Maths. Luckily, she was sat beside Benny, and Ethan was sat on the other side of him.

"This morning, Hannah was being nice to me and asked if she could trust me." Ethan explained to Benny.
He laughed. "Dude, it's a trap!"

"I knew it! The next time I saw her, she swore like my dad in traffic."

Olivia shook her head. "No, she likes you! All girls are like that. They pretend to not like you when, really, they do."

"No," Benny disagreed. "There's two sides to every girl, like a coin: heads: she's crazy, tails: same as heads."

Olivia raised an eyebrow. "Er, no! That's not true!" She protested.

"Look, I can prove it, watch this." He pointed at Hannah.

"Hey, Kammy, I love your skirt!" She smiled.
"Thanks!" Kammy answered.
"Heads." Benny said.

Hannah then walked away and appeared in the other door. She knocked over someone's books and laughed. "Oops, I am so sorry!"
"Tails." Benny said. "Good luck with that."

Olivia rolled her eyes. "You two know nothing."

***

Olivia, Ethan and Benny were sat at a lunch table eating and talking about how strange Hannah was acting.

She was sat across from them so they'd have to be subtle. When Rory walked past she threw something at him. "Ow!" He yelled.

Hannah stood up and punched the air. "Yes! Now that was a three pointer! Who else wants some of this?"

"If she asks you out, you better say yes." Benny whispered to Ethan.

She then saw the three teens and Ethan started to panic. "She's coming over! What do we do?"
"Just act natural." Benny said.
"Well, I'm naturally nervous so..."
Olivia rolled her eyes.

Hannah leant over the table, glaring at Ethan and Benny. "Baby still crying because he can't be a superman in the yearbook?"

Benny scoffed. "Superman? Please! He's a bit too retro, a little too old school."

Hannah snorted and tipped his food on his tray onto, luckily it was just a snack bar and a wrapped up sandwich. "Awww. And it was such as nice nerd shirt." She said before walking away.

"Bitch." Olivia mumbled.
"I don't care how much of a crush she has on you. She just made Benny's list." Benny said, through gritted teeth.

***

The next day, Olivia was stood outside with Sarah talking to some of their friends.

Their attention was drawn away from each-other, when they heard the sound a car coming closer.

To their surprise, it was Benny. He was wearing a leather jacket, a helmet, sunglasses and driving a go-cart.

Olivia put her hands over her mouth to contain her laughter. She noticed that Sarah was doing the same.

Benny stepped out of the go-cart and pretended to lock it. As he approached them, Olivia also noticed that he was chewing on a toothpick.

Once Benny came across Olivia, he took off his helmet and smirked. "Hey, babe. Like my new ride?" He asked, taking the toothpick out of his mouth.

"You bought a go-cart?" Sarah questioned.
"Rented." He then turned his attention to Sarah, then back towards Olivia. "But I'm thinking of stealing it." He smirked, again.

Olivia laughed. "Benny, are you okay?"
"Are you sleepwalking again?" Sarah asked.

"No, but I am walking out of this town." Benny kept his eyes on Olivia. "So, if you want a shot at this, then you better hurry up."

Olivia scoffed. "Are you sure you're okay?"
Benny licked his lips and stepped closer to Olivia. "I've got an idea."

Olivia raised an eyebrow.
"Come with me." Benny smirked.
"Uhm-" Before Olivia could argue, Benny grabbed hold of her arm and started pulling her into school.

She turned back to Sarah, who cluelessly threw her arms in the air, before walking away.

"Great..." Olivia mumbled, before turning to Benny and wincing. "Can you loosen your grip a little? What the hell is wrong with you?"

Benny didn't answer. He dragged her into the dark room and to her surprise, Hannah was tied to a chair with tape over her mouth. Olivia gasped. "What the-"

She turned around, expecting to see Benny, but he wasn't there.

"Smile!"
Olivia spun back around to see Benny stood with an old camera. "Is that the camera that Hannah was gonna use-"

She was cut off by the sound of her picture being taken. She squinted at the bright flash.
"Benny, this isn't you-!"
"You've got that right." He smirked, taking out another toothpick and putting it in between his teeth.

"Now, I've just gotta get this development, and then I've got myself an evil girlfriend. Next on the list is an evil best friend." Benny said, walking away from her.

Olivia took this as a chance to run. "Stay away from me and stay away from Ethan!" She yelled, opening the door.

"No!" Benny yelled.
He couldn't catch Olivia up. By the time he had reached the door, she had already turned a corner and was out of sight.

***

Olivia ran down the crowded hallways until she found Sarah, Benny and Ethan stood by Sarah's locker.

"Benny!" She gasped, once her eyes locked with his.
"He's got an evil twin, we know." Ethan told her.

"Woah, woah, woah." Benny said, putting his hands on Olivia's shoulders. "Are you okay?"
"I think he may have made a copy of me, as well." Olivia panted.

Sarah's eyes widened. "What?! Is that what he did?!"
Benny's head snapped towards Sarah. "You knew about this?"
Olivia nodded, ignoring Benny's comment.

"We've gotta destroy the negatives before more evil twins are created!" Ethan told them.

"Sarah, you and me are gonna stop Hannah." Ethan said, before pointing at both Benny and Olivia. "You two find your evil twins."

Olivia exhaled before groaning. "But I just ran all this way."
Benny laughed. "You heard the man, let's go!"

***

"So," Benny began as the two quickly walked down the now empty school corridors, since the school pictures were being taken. "what did Evil Benny say to you?"

Olivia shrugged, looking around. "Not much. Stuff jerks say, you know?"
"Did he... you know, do anything?" Benny awkwardly asked.

Olivia laughed. "What do you mean?"
Benny turned to her. "You know what I mean."
Olivia sighed. "You're right. And no, he didn't."

Benny breathed out a sigh of relief. "Okay, good, because if he did I would've-"

"Would've done what?" Someone asked, making the two spin around.

Benny's and Olivia's eyes widened when they saw their negatives stood at the other end of the hallway.

Benny's twin was still wearing his leather jacket, with yet another toothpick to chew on. Olivia's twin's hair was slightly messier than the real Olivia's hair, but apart from that, she looked the same.

The negatives strode up towards Benny and Olivia.
"What would you do, huh?" Evil Benny continued to mock Benny. "Cast a spell from the book your grandma gave you?"

Evil Benny threw an arm around Evil Olivia's shoulder and pulled her closer.
Benny and Olivia's eyes widened when the two began to passionately kiss each-other.

Luckily, the awkwardness didn't last for long, because they pulled away after a few seconds.

Evil Benny looked at Olivia. "You know, I prefer this version of you." He smirked, referring to Olivia's negative copy.

"I've got this, Olivia." Benny said, clicking his knuckles.
Olivia turned to him. "Are you crazy? He'll destroy you!"
Benny shot her an offended look. "Hey!"

Evil Olivia laughed. "This is gonna be easy." She smirked.
Evil Olivia unwrapped herself from her evil boyfriend's embrace and grabbed the collar of Olivia's jacket.

She pinned her against the locker and Benny cried out.
Before he could do anything, Evil Benny threw him to the lockers opposite them. "I promised the boring version of Olivia that I'd have myself an evil best friend by the end of the day." Evil Benny smirked as he towered over Benny.

Benny pushed himself up. "Leave Ethan alone!"
Evil Benny chuckled. "We'll see about that." He said, before running away.

Benny looked in between the two Olivia's, and the negative copy of himself.
"Go!" Olivia yelled. "I've got this!"

Although Benny was worried. He believed her. He knew that she was strong and that she could fight for herself.

So, Benny chased his evil twin down the hallway, leaving Olivia with her negative copy.

"Please don't tell me he's your boyfriend." Evil Olivia said as she kept Olivia pinned against the locker.

Olivia built up the strength to push Evil Olivia off her and onto the floor. "Please don't tell me he's your boyfriend." She mocked. "I mean, seriously, he's a jerk."

Evil Olivia gritted her teeth and hit Olivia's head with hers.
Olivia cried out. She got up and clasped her hands over her forehead.

She took a few steps back before taking her hands away. Evil Olivia smirked. She was about to run and catch up with her evil boyfriend, but Olivia charged at her. She knocked her back onto the cold, hard floor and slapped her.

Olivia then reached into her negative's jean pocket, hoping to find the copy. Her eyes widened when she felt it. Olivia took it out and smirked.

She grabbed her twin's collar, like she did to her before, and smashed the back of her head against the floor.

Olivia got up and tucked some stray strands of hair behind her hair, tidying herself up. As Evil Olivia was struggling to get up, Olivia smirked and held up the copy.

"That really was easy." Olivia teased, referring to what her negative said before.
She teared the copy in half and her twin cried out. Within seconds, she had disappeared.

Olivia breathed out a sigh of relief, before looking around the hallway. "Now I've gotta find Benny and hope that he's gotten rid of his twin."

***

"You're such a jerk!" Olivia heard someone yell. It sounded like Benny. She groaned when she looked at the sign on the door in front of her.

"Do I really want to go into the boys' bathroom?" She asked herself.

"I know you are but what am I?" The similar voice retorted.

Olivia ran in just as Benny pushed Evil Benny against one of the walls of the cubicles. He took the copy and threw Evil Benny to the ground.

Benny ran into the toilets but Evil Benny took hold of his leg. Olivia ran towards him and kicked him hard enough so that he'd loose his grip. He grabbed his leg in pain.

Benny threw the copy down the toilet and flushed it. Olivia watched Evil Benny disappear and Benny step out of the cubicle, almost breathless.

"You okay?" She asked him, her hand on his shoulder.
"I just myself down the toilet, I'm gonna need some time." Benny sighed. "Did you get rid of your twin?"

Olivia nodded and Benny smirked. "I knew you could do it."

Olivia flashed him a smile. "We better find Ethan and Sarah."

***

Benny agreed to walk Olivia home that day. Olivia giggled at the sight of Benny looking so happy that he got his camera back. He looked at her and furrowed his brows.

"What? This means grandma won't spank me... with lightening."
This time Olivia burst out laughing. "Right, okay."

"It was pretty weird seeing an evil version of us... as a... you know-" Benny began, changing the subject.

"A couple?" Olivia chuckled. "I know. It was more awkward than weird."
Benny laughed. "True. Maybe if I buy a leather jacket, sunglasses, a go-cart and carry toothpicks with me, I might get a girlfriend." He joked.

Olivia giggled. "You'll probably end up getting slapped. Besides, you're much better this way."

Benny's eyes locked with Olivia's and he smiled. "Thanks."
Olivia cracked a grin. "The jacket was pretty hot though."

Benny playfully slapped her and laughed. "Yeah, right. Funny."