I made a Red Dead Redemption 2 x Reader scenario book so if you are interested please go check it out and I hope you enjoy it.

Coach:

He didn't give up, he kept searching. He didn't care for getting off the island anymore and to safety, his new goal was to find you and get to safety together. He spent weeks searching everywhere, the zombies seemed no issue anymore with how easily he was killing them with the rage and despair he felt. So when you finally saw him again, he looked like a mad man: holding a bloody bat, covered in blood splatters, panting heavily. His look of exhaustion and anger turned to one of uncertainty when he laid his eyes upon you then relief and hope, calling your name in a questioning manner, as if asking if it's really you or if he finally went insane. When you hurried to him and said his name, he was quick to drop the bat and run to you. You didn't even have time to open your arms to hug him as he had you already in the tight hug he ever given, lifting you off the ground a little even.

Rochelle:

There were many times she slid down a wall, the strength in her legs gone, just crying, feeling so hopeless, crying there is no way you survived in this. She was very thankful for Coach in those times, because she doubts she would have made it without him pulling her back up and sternly telling her to not have such little faith in you and that he's sure you are out there somewhere. And she was so glad she kept going; because one day, she saw you. She froze for a second before she ran to you, calling your name with such hope, sadness, and happiness. She threw her arms around you and held you tightly, tears just flowing down without control before she pulled away to examine your face, make sure this is real then she happily said your name again before saying you are finally back.

Ellis:

When you suddenly went missing he yelled your name while running around, which he realized was a very terrible idea very quickly when a huge horde came running to him because of all the noise he was making. But he really didn't care, he will kill as many hordes as he needs to if it means you will hear him shouting your name. As he finished killing a horde and was about to yell your name, suddenly a hand covered his mouth and someone whisper yelled if he's gone insane. He twirled around and just stared in shock then happily said your name before throwing his arms around you then saying you suddenly went missing so of course he was going insane. Then he proudly said shouting your name did work though since you are here now.

Nick:

He was so furious when you suddenly went missing, angrily rambling how there is a reason the rule "stick together" was made and it was to prevent this from happening. He angrily ranted a lot, not even to anyone in particular, just needing to vent to let out his anger. He needed to do it, otherwise he would be even more stressed and unable to focus on surviving and finding you. When he finally did find you, he yelled your name, suddenly all his anger forgotten. He ran to you so quickly before grasping your arms tightly, asking if you got injured anywhere and where you went off to. He asked so many questions so you had to kiss him to shut him up then answered all his questions. After that, whenever he wasn't using his weapon, he was holding your hand tightly, always making sure you are aside or at least near him.