Aries: Yunyun

Taurus: Wiz

Gemini: Megumin

Cancer: Iris

Leo: Darkness/Dustiness Ford Lalatina

Virgo: Eris/Chris

Libra: Yunyun

Scorpio: Satou Kazuma (You could go for Female Kazuma if you'd like.)

Sagittarius: Wolbach

Capricorn: Arue

Aquarius: Sena

Pisces: Lean