Sarah was screaming in her sleep and shaking, "NO! Arlong! J-j....GET OFF OF ME!!!"

"Sarah....," Buggy gently tried to shake her awake. He held her face gently, "baby, it's me, Buggy, I'm here....you're safe. You're having a nightmare."

Sarah finally woke up and saw Buggy's face. She then broke down. She pulled him tightly and gripped on him as she sobbed, "they were...r-raping me..."

Buggy didn't need to ask who. He heard her say Arlong's name, and he was guessing the other monster would be the Joker.

"It's alright baby, it was just a horrible nightmare....," he held her tightly and stroked her face, brushing her tears away, "I'm here and I'll always protect you. They might think you're vulnerable now that Arthur has gone, but I'll protect you with my life."

Sarah looked up at him still crying. "Please don't ever leave me. Never ever. Even if I get angry and tell you to."

Buggy smiled slightly and shook his head, "I won't ever leave you. No matter how angry you get. You can be mad at me and even hate me, but I'll still be there to protect you always."

Sarah then pulled him close, "...I love you, Buggy. I'm so scared without you."

Buggy held her close, "I love you too, sweetie....you don't have to be afraid. I'll never leave you, my love."

He then blushed for calling her that and was worried it might upset her.

Sarah then held his face and kissed him. "I need you..."

"I need you too baby," he held her chin gently and kissed her back softly.

"....do you think...we could have a baby?"

"....." Buggy's eyebrows shot up in surprise. He had not been expecting that. But he smiled "....the amount of sex we have, it wouldn't take long that's for sure."

Sarah giggled and brushed his cheek."but for tonight," she took his hand and placed between her legs, "I want you to comfort me by touching me...all night, my captain~~~I want to come all night for you."

"That won't be a problem," he smirked, "It'll be my pleasure to give you pleasure, honey," he then cupped her face and kissed her as he rubbed between her legs over her undergarments, teasing her, "....as soon as you're wet for me, we'll loose these—," he pulled at her panties playfully.

She blushed and moaned softly as his fingers slid down between her legs onto her cilt, "ahhh, B-Buggy..."

He rubbed on her clit softly with the tip of his finger, then gradually increased the pressure, rubbing her more, "I love touching you, baby."

"I love it too. It feels so good when you touch me like this," she moaned softly, "oh my gosh, Buggy. It feels so good."

"I'm glad you like it, Sarah," he slipped his hand inside her panties and dragged his finger slowly over her, "mhm, you're wet for me, baby," he then slipped a finger in her slowly and began moving it in and out.

"I will always be ready for you, Bug', I love it so much, your finger feels so good in my p*ssy. Even when you twirl it around like when you lick me with your tongue. You have magical fingers, you know how to make me come for you..."

"Hey easy tiger, you're going to make my ego even bigger than it already is," he joked, as he then twirled his finger around inside like she'd just said, "....I love touching your perfect little p*ssy. It feels so tight and wet, and you taste soooo good," he kissed the side of her neck.

"Oh, Buggy. You're so silly~, I would do the same for you. I would stroke that cock of yours and allow you to f*ck my mouth." He shivered when she said that, "but you are only touching me. I know you want your cock inside of me and f*ck me so hard to make me come again and again...and again," she was teasing him.

"Tease," Buggy chuckled. He took her hand and placed it on his crotch area, "....see how hard you make me just by saying those things," he then removed her hand, "but you're right....this isn't about my hard cock being inside you, it's about my magical fingers," he then slid another finger in her and moved them faster.

Sarah gasped throwing her head back, "ahhh, Bu-Buggy..."

She squirmed and whined, "I will come for you, baby. I will. I love this. I love your touches. I am so weak in your grasp~~~"

Buggy smirked and pulled her closer and repoistioned her so she was laid in front of him, her back resting against his bare chest. He continued to finger her, as he rest his chin on her shoulder. His other hand wandered to her breasts, ".....am I allowed to touch these, or are they off limits too?"

Sarah moaned, "that turns me on, Buggy~" she held his hand that is squeezing her breast, "oh...sh*t." That was the first she said that word and Buggy chuckled for she said his favorite cuss word.

"You can even make that word sexy," he chuckled. He then licked his fingers and thumb and teased her nipple with them, moaning softly as he watched it harden. His member was so hard now she could feel it poking her in the back.

"Oh sh!t, Buggy, f*ck it, just put it in me! I want you to f*ck me so hard!" She moaned.

"Sarah babyyy.....this is about me pleasuring you, not me," he kissed the side of her neck and her shoulder as he fingered in her faster.

She couldn't take it anymore and whined and squirmed, "but it feels so good." She grabbed the back of his head and kissed him deeply.

He kissed her back as he squeezed her other breast and teased her nipple, "Once you cum on my fingers, then I'll let you have my cock, baby."

Sarah gasped as finally came onto his fingers. He smirked and then licked his fingers and closed his eyes, "mhm... sooooo good."

She then was laid down on her back and Buggy leaned in with his body pressed against hers as they kissed. She cupped his face as they kissed. "I love you, Captain Buggy."

"I love you too, Sarah...like, I mean....really....love you," he traced his fingers over her lips as he kissed her face.

"....," she really loved him too, she was just still shy to say it.