"No." Lucy said straight up.

"Come on Lu-chan! You have to! It's a dare, no backing out or you have to wear the hat of shame for a whole weekend." Levy said and Lucy shuddered at the mention of the hat of shame.

"Yes Lucy, you have to. Never back down from a challenge." Erza added.

"But please Mira! Please change the dare! I pick truth! Please!" Lucy got on her knees and folded her hands together. "Mira please. I can't. I mean he already likes someone else. It's obvious..."

"No!" Mira yelled. "You two are meant to be! NALU FOR THE WIN! YOU ARE MY OTP!"

"NaLu?" Levy asked.

"OTP?" Erza tilted her head.

"NaLu is the first 2 letters of Natsu's name and the Lu is the first two letters in lucy's name." The girls "oh"d. "And OTP is One True Pairing"

"Well go on Lucy-san!" Wendy cheered.

"You got this Lucy!" Erza cheered as well.

"Do a good job Lu-chan!"

"I want 30 NaLu babies! You hear me? 30!!!"

Lisanna stayed silent the whole time.

"Well I guess I'm off. I'll have to get Virgo to dig me a whole to hide in for the rest of my life."

"Make sure it's at least 10 seconds Lucy~" Mira sang.

"I hate you all."

"Sure you do." Levy sarcastically replied.

"Yeah Levy but guess what? You're next." Lucy smirked.

All the girls giggled and then Mira pushed Lucy out the door yelling. "Kiss him good!"

Lucy walked down the hallway. She almost broke down and cried because she knew how this would end. He'd say how he liked Lisanna and she'd probably die. So many ways to die. But this would be by far the worst way. But he is a really nice and protective person. He should be with Lisanna. She could probably make him happier and she is much stronger than her and she's really pretty. Lucy sighed. "I don't stand a chance against her." She looked up to see she was at the guys room. They were currently on vacation because of their victory in the GMG. She hesitated. Thinking of the worst senario. He could just push her away in disgust. He could start yelling at her about how he didn't feel that way. She finally knocked.

"It's about time you got he- Lucy? What are you doing here?" Gray answered the door looking confused on why she was here. She walked past him without answering

"NATSU WHERE ARE YOU?" She yelled.

"Is that Erza?! Natsu yelled from the kitchen. "I swear it wasn't me it was ice princess! Don't hurt me please."

She walked to the kitchen. "Oh it's just you Luce. I was scared Erza was gonna hurt me."

"Yeah..."

"Is something wrong? You seem sad."

"What? No... I'm just scared of... something..." Lucy looked away. She could feel tears welling up in her eyes.

"Luce? Are you crying." Right as he said that the tears started falling freely.

"No. Of course not." She wiped her eyes and looked down.

"Lucy. Why are you crying?" He asked seriously.

"Because *sob* I- you- him- her- I-" she broke down and fell towards him crying. "Why, Natsu? Why? Am I not pretty enough? Am I fat like Happy always says? Am I too weak?" She sobbed louder. "Natsu?" She looked at him. "Do you think I'm ugly? Don't lie to me either." She burried her head in his chest.

"Lucy... We all know your not ugly."

"But do YOU think I'm ugly?"

"No of course not! Every girl in our guild is really pretty"

"Especially Lisanna right?" She frowned against him.

"Well yeah Lisanna is pretty too but..." He stopped.

"Okay well I should probably do what I came here for. She backed away from him and wiped her eyes.

"Lucy you shouldn't cry over that kind of stuff anymore." Natsu said serious.

"I know. Now come here." He took a step forward.  "Closer." He took 2 more steps closer. "Closer." He was now right by her face. "Hey Natsu. I apologize in advance for what I'm about to do."

"Why would you be apol-" She planted her lips on his and he was wide eyed. 10 seconds later she backed away.

"I'm sorry. I'm so so sorry." She said as she backed away then ran out the door crashing into Gray on her way out.

"Yo flame brain! What did you do to her! Hey I'm talking to y- Natsu?" He waved his hand in front of his face. "Hey ash breath! You there? Hello? Snap out of it!"

"Lucy just kissed me." Natsu mumbled.

"What? Quit mumbling!"

"Lucy kissed me." He said louder this time.

"She what?! Then why are you still here?!"

With Lucy and the Girls

"Why did it have to be him!! Why couldn't it be some random non-dense, dragon slayer, cute, nice, idiot?" Lucy cried in Levy's shoulder. "You're lucky Lisanna it's obvious he likes you, He even said you're very pretty." She sobbed louder.

"Hey Wendy, can you please go get some tissues." Levy asked.

"H-Hai."

"Oh Lu-chan I'm so sorry. But it's not like it's Gajeel."

"Yeah but *sob* likes you back. Natsu likes someone else! *sob* But she's really lucky."

"Lucy I shall go over there and he will be punished for this."

"No Erza, its not his fault he doesn't like me like that." Lucy laughed. " I guess it just wasn't meant to be and I'm okay with that. But Juvia, Gray does really like you! He even said so to Gajeel! And Gajeel is way in love with you Levy-chan! Even Romeo has a little crush on Wendy."

"I got the tissues Lucy-san!"

"Well anyway, Juvia knows that Natsu loves Lucy! But Lucy is being dumb." Juvia said.

"No, Natsu does like me right Lucy?" Lisanna asked.

"It's obvious." Lucy said sadly. "Don't worry."

"Hey don't be all negative about it Lucy! There's plenty of other guys for you!" Lisanna smiled.

"Yeah you're probably right. Natsu just isn't the one for me. He deserves someone like Lisanna." Lucy smiled sadly. "I'm gonna go to bed, see you guys tomorrow. We're still going to the beach right?"

"Yup!"

"Awesome,  see you guys tomorrow!"

"Goodnight!"

"I'm gonna go to bed too! Night!" Lisanna called to them as she left.

"Night"

"Okay we need to talk." Mira demanded.

"Yeah defiantly. Juvia needs to know how to get Love Ri- Lucy to smile again. A real smile." Juvia said.

"Well, we all know why Lucy is upset." Erza said.

"I never thought it would be Natsu-san that would make Lucy-san sad." Wendy frowned.

"Same here! I mean Natsu is Lu-chan's best friend well besides me."

"Well I don't understand why Lucy likes him! She can do a lot better! With a chest like that, she can get any guy!" Erza said. "I just don't like seeing her hurt by the one person who would never hurt her..."

"Yeah, it's sad to see her all-" Levy was interrupted by a knock at the door.

"Oh that must be the pizza we ordered after Lucy left to... yeah..." Erza said. "I'll get it. She went to the living room and opened the door. "Natsu? You got a lot of nerve coming here."

"Where is she?"

"Oh Lisanna's sleeping."

"I'm not looking for Lisanna! Where's Lucy?"

"Oh. Well she's sleeping too."

"I need to talk to her."

"Why!?" Erza yelled. "So she can cry all over again! It was just a dare! Nobody was supposed to get hurt..." Erza looked at the bedroom door. Then sighed "She's in there."

He nodded and left for the room.

He opened the door and shut it quietly. "Hey Luce, you awake?" No response. "I guess not. Well I'm sorry... I don't know what happened back there, and you have no idea how much it hurts to watch you cry." He sighed. "I hope you can forgive me. I love you." He walked to the door and took one last look at her and smiled. Then he left, shutting the door behind him.

"I love you too, stupid..."

There! My second NaLu fanfiction! I am just writing and writing anyway! please tell me what you think and please don't hesitate to tell me anything that was wrong with the story or if you maybe (probably not) would like a second part. I doubt it but thanks for reading!

~Angel_Vanessa