Once Max and Jess entered the living room they looked super tired so they agreed that they would just go eat the cake.

third person:

Everyone walked to where the cake was.," okay so who wants a finger?" Jess asked as she cut a slice. Max raised his hand and Jess put the cake on the plate and handed it to him.,"Thanks." he said giving her a kiss before heading to the living room. she gave everyone else a slice of cake and they all went to the living room.

Red pov:

I sat down and had to hold back a gag. On the cake was a severed finger! Jess was munching on it with a huge smile on her face so I plucked it off the cake and asked her," You want it. I won't have room for it." she looked at his direction and nodded taking it. Sky and barney did the same with shelby and ross.

Shelby pov:

After eating the delicous fingers I started to enjoy the red velvet cake. My favorite part was when we met the middle. in the middle we had added blood mixed with the chocolate goonash. As we all reached the middle barney sky and red spit it out. ," WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT!" Sky yelled. They ran to the kitchen to was their mouths but spit the water out. They ran to the carpet and moved it to leave.," Where you going?" I asked walking up to them with my trusty knife. they had a scared look as they jumped down and left back to their homes.