Chapter Fifteen: A Party? Part II

Without U - Beach Goons

Millie's P.O.V

The loud sound of music came blasting out of a house filled with teenagers. As Sadie drove closer to the house the music came louder. More and more teenagers came rushing in as fast as they could to get to the party. My stomach feels a little nauseous thinking what would everyone think that a person like me would be in a place like this. Sadie notices my nervousness and grabs my hand. "Don't worry Millie, just get in and be yourself," She says as she locks arms with mine.

"Okay," I said with a shaky breath. We both head inside with our arms still locked. Teenagers were tight together dancing to the music with red cups in their hands. 

"I'm gonna go find Caleb okay?" Sadie says as she runs off into the crowd. She was long gone even before I could approve of her leaving. What the hell am I supposed to do? I walked around the crowd of sweaty bodies going through every room in the house. I reached a hallway filled with several doors that had teenagers making out or socializing. I found a door that said bathroom but was occupied. 

I open up other doors but end up finding couples undressing themselves causing me to quickly shut the door. I walk around the house again finding a less crowded room that had a couple of people hanging in. There was a sofa that was on the side of the room. The room was pretty dim which made it harder to see who was who. 

There were two people that were sitting on that couch. One curly haired boy with a blonde girl sitting next to him. They both take a sip of there red cups at the same time but the blonde finishes first and leans close to the boy giving him a peck on the cheek. I hear a familiar chuckle coming from the boy's mouth. More like an awkward chuckle. I squint my eyes taking a couple steps closer.

"Finn?" I ask grabbing his attention. He quickly gets up from the sofa running toward me.

"Millie!" He says excitedly as he lifts me up from the ground with arms wrapped around my waist tightly giving me a tight hug. I wrap my arms around his neck as he spins me around in the air and gently placed me back on the ground. 

"The hell was that for?" I ask chuckling as I get my balance back.

"Just got excited," He says looking down at the ground as he scratches his neck. 

"I didn't think you're gonna make it," He says with as he quickly changes the subject.

"Well, I'm here," I said as I pull my skirt down a little.

"Wow, you look amazing, never seen you show that much skin," Finn says as he looks at me up and down. I consciously pull down my top hoping it'll show less of my stomach. 

"It was Sadie's idea not mine," I said annoyed. I pull my eyebrows close together suddenly spotting a cherry red kiss mark on his left cheek.

"Who gave that to you?" I ask with an eyebrow raised while crossing my arms. He lifts up his hand touching the red mark on his face feeling the texture of the lipstick.

"That was from me," I look up finding Maddie with a tight grey dress on her with bright cherry red lipstick placed on her lips. How am I not surprised? 

"You remember Maddie," Finn says as he places his hand on her shoulder.

"How could I," I said as I forcefully smile at her. She sends me a fake smile as she leans closer to Finn. The tension of awkwardness spread through the air causing Finn to quickly do something about it. 

"Have you gotten a drink yet?" Finn asks as he raises an eyebrow at me.

"Oh, no I don't dri-"

"Let's go get you a drink, you wanna come too Maddie?" Finn asks as he grabs my hand.

"I'll pass, don't wanna drink with inexperienced drinkers," Maddie says as she flips her hair and walks away. I roll my eyes while Finn wasn't looking. 

"Maddie's missing out, let's go get you a drink," He says as he pulls me through the crowd of teenagers and into the kitchen. Several bowls of chips were laid in a row. Sitting next to them was a large punch bowl filled with several colors mixed together with a large stack of red cups leaning next to it. I stare at the mixed colors inside the punch bowl scrunching my nose with disgust. 

"What is that?" I ask Finn as he pulls out two red cups from the stack of red cups.

"A bunch of different drinks mixed in one, Caleb made it," He says as he starts pouring the odd liquid in the cup in his hand and hands it to me. 

"It's surprisingly really good." He says as he starts pouring more of the odd liquid in another cup and takes a long sip.

"You try it," He says as he pushes the cup closer to me.

"Uh, maybe later," I said as I put down my cup on the kitchen counter.

"Come on Mills, loosen up a little," he says as he pokes my stomach annoyingly. I giggle feeling ticklish. Finn notices my reaction and pokes me, even more, making me laugh harder.

"Okay, okay I'll loosen up, just stop tickling me," I said breathlessly. He finally stops poking my bear stomach giving me a breath of relief. I notice Maddie standing a couple of meters away with a group of girls giving me the biggest death glare. 

"What's wrong?" Finn asks grabbing my attention.

"Oh, nothing. Are you planning on keeping that kiss mark on the whole day?" I asked crossing my arms over my chest. Finn raises an eyebrow. 

"What? You jealous of this masterpiece that Maddie made?" I roll my eyes as Finn points out the "masterpiece" on his cheek.

"I can definitely do a better one," I said with a challenging tone.

"Oh, yeah? Prove it." Finn says with his arms crossed.

"Fine," I pull the collar of his flannel making him come closer to me. I place my lips on his right cheek giving me the full view of his tiny freckles. I pull away letting go of his collar. 

"Now this is a masterpiece," I said as I point to the cheek that I kissed. His right cheek now has a kiss mark with a blended color of black and beige. My cheeks felt warm from the feeling of his skin making me feel eager to kiss him again. Finn's cheeks had a tint of pink but quickly faded away. 

"Millie, Finn" Both Finn and I turn to the direction of our names. It was Caleb.

"We're playing a game here, you guys wanna play?" Caleb asks.

"Do you wanna play?" Finn asks. I shrug my shoulders not really caring.

"We'll play," Finn yells back and grabs my hand again following Caleb to his large garage. Teenagers were surrounding the place but not as much as inside. A ping pong table was in the middle of the place filled with red cups lined up like a triangle on each side. Sadie was near the ping pong table with a drink in her hand talking to Grace. I notice Maddie walk in a couple minutes after we got here. 

"What are we playing?" I ask Caleb. I hear people snicker at my question.

"Beer Pong, except with a twist," Caleb says as he grabs several ping pong balls in the cabinet of his garage.

"Isn't it obvious enough?" Maddie asks annoyed as she leans against that wall.

"She didn't know Maddie, chill," Finn said back.

"Who wants to go first?" Caleb asks grabbing everyone's attention.

"I'll go," Finn says raising his hand walking up to the ping pong table letting go of my hand.

"Alright Finn, who wants to play against him?" Caleb asks.

"I'll play," A tall brown haired boy as he walks closer to the ping pong table. 

"Alright it's settled," Caleb says pouring some kind of alcohol in each cup.

"What's your name man?" Finn asking the brown haired boy.

"Jacob, Jacob Sartorius," The brown haired boy says with a mischievous smirk on his lips. Finn lifts his hand to shake Jacob's. Jacob stares at his hand with a wider smile on his lips as if he's gotten an idea.

"How about we make a deal, If I win I get to take that pretty one over there home," He says pointing at my direct. I look behind me finding no one standing there realizing the person he's pointing at is me. The whole garage became quite eager to hear the challenge. 

"And if you win, you get to take home the girl of your choice, deal?" Jacob says as he lifts his hand up for Finn to shake. Finn raises an eyebrow debating if he should or shouldn't take the deal.

"Bullshit!!" I yell making everyone's eyes land on me.

"I picked a feisty one didn't I, what's wrong pretty one, you afraid I'll lose?" Jacob says stepping closer to me lift my chin up to come closer to him. Anger spread through Finn's face noticing Jacob's actions.

"No dumbass," I said as I push his hand away from my chin.

"It's bullshit that you see me as some kind of trophy to win, just so you know I'm an actual human being not some kind of prized possession," I said aggressively. Sadie quickly walks up to me noticing my anger. "Millie, chill it's just a game," Sadie whispers as she grabs my arm hoping it'll calm me down.

"No Sadie, I won't chill," I said as I tug my arm away from her grip.

"In fact, I'll play against him right here right now," I said as I point at Jacob. I mischevious smirk lit on his face as I glare at him. I walk up to the ping pong table making people cheer for my bravery. 

"Are you sure Mills? Have you ever played before?" Finn asks worryingly leaning close to me.

"Nope, but I'll wing it," I said as I study the structure of the ping pong table.

"Fine, but I'm staying right boy you're side to help you out alright?" Finn asks as he speaks closely to my ear with his body an inch away from mine. I nodded agreeing with Finn with my eyebrows knit together. 

"What if you win? A makeout session with you?" I scrunch my nose in disgust.

"Fuck no, I'll get a hundred bucks from you," I said with my arms crossed. I hear others including Finn chuckle as I bark back to Jacob. Jacobs mischievous look quickly turned into an annoyed one.

"What if I win? Will I get a two-hour blowjob?" He asks sending me a wide smile on his lips. I roll my eyes feeling even more disgusted. That's even worse than making out for him.

"No bragging rights, now let's start," A crowd of laughter spread through the room.

"Alright, heads or tails Millie?" Caleb asks as he spins the quarter around his fingers.

"Heads," Caleb nods and tosses the coin in the air. The ringing sound of the coin echoed the room. the quarter finally stopped bouncing and landed on heads. 

"Alright Millie, you're up first," He says as he tosses me the ping pong ball.

"All you have to do is bounce the ball on the table and let it land in one of Jacob's cups," Finn whispers leaning closer to me. I bounce the ball on the table hoping it'll land in a cup. The bounce hitting the side of the cup and bounces off the table. Jacob chuckles at my failure and pickups the ball and does the same. This time it landed on one of my cups perfectly. 

"Now what do I do?" I ask Finn softly as I pull out the ping pong ball from the cup.

"You drink it," He says disappointingly. Damn it, I bring the cup close to my lips letting the liquid flow inside me. I squint in disgust at the bitter taste of alcohol. The game went on which lasted about half an hour. Loud cheers would fill the room when Jacob and I throw a ball inside one of the cups. I was losing which meant that I'm drinking the most right now. After drinking a couple of cups I started to feel drowsy and unbalanced. The more drinks I drank, the less concentrated I am in making the ball bounce inside one of the cups. Finn stayed by my side the whole game giving me some help from time to time. 

There were times when I had to lean on Finn to stay balanced. He kept his hands around my waist to keep me steady, it was working pretty well. Jacob bounced the ping pong ball on the table making it land on the last cup that was on my side. Loud cheers spread through the room giving me a headache. Jacob only had two cups left, I was so close to winning. I lift up my cup pulling out the ping pong ball and throwing it at Jacob with him catching it. I roll my eyes at his catching skills and jug the whole cup making me feel even dizzier. The game finally ended with Jacob winning.

"I'm officially the winner," Jacob says as he walks closer to me with his arms in a fight up high making the room cheer even more.

"Good job Mills, I'm impressed especially since it was your first time," He says letting go of me. My balance started to disappear making Finn place his arms around me again. I nod my head with dizziness in my eyes. 

"Since I won why don't you give me a victory kiss right here," Jacob says pointing to his cheek.

"In your dreams asshole!" I yelled pushing him away from me. I place my arm around Finn to stay standing with my body leaning against his. I shut my eyes leaning my head against his head feeling drowsier.

"You know what Finn, I could take her home myself, she doesn't look so good," Jacob says grabbing my arm.

"I don't think she wants to be near you at all," Finn says as he pulls my arm back away from Jacob. I open my eyes looking at my surroundings. I spot Sadie leaning close to Caleb giving him a kiss and shut my eyes again. 

"Finn I'm tired," I said placing all my weight on Finn.

"Oh come on, Millie you wanna come with me right?" Jacob asks leaning his face close to mine. I nod my head no feeling my eyelids feel heavy. 

"I'm taking you home Mills," Finn says as he lifts my feet up from the ground as I fall fast asleep.

<<>>

Finn's P.O.V

I have a bad feeling about Jacob. The way he looks at Millie like she's a piece of meat, it's disgusting. I spotted him a couple of times staring at her ass. I was surprised at how fast Millie understood beer pong since it was her first time. I didn't want to leave her side. I felt like Jacob would do something to her if I leave her behind. Millie got really drunk after drinking a couple of cups. Millie had one cup left on her side and Jacob had two, they were very close to breaking a tie. Jacob was able to make the ball fall in Millie's cup making him the winner.

"I'm officially the winner," Jacob says in triumph walking closer to me.

"Good job Mills, I'm impressed especially since it was your first time," I said to Millie as I let go of her making her lose her balance again. I quickly catch her making her be balanced again. She nods her head with a lazy smile on her lips. 

"Since I won why don't you give me a victory kiss right here," Jacob says pointing to his cheek.

"In your dreams asshole!" Millie yelled pushing Jacob away from her. Millie places her arm around my neck to stay standing with her body leaning against me. I lose my balance a little but quickly catch it as I place my arm around her. Jacob crosses his arm annoyed by Millie's answer.

"You know what Finn, I could take her home myself, she doesn't look so good," Jacob says grabbing Millie's arm. I quickly pull it away from him pulling her closer to me. I don't trust Jacob with Millie.

"I don't think she wants to be near you at all," I said with my eyebrows tide together.

"Finn I'm tired," Millie says placing all her weight on me.

"Oh come on, Millie you wanna come with me right?" Jacob asks leaning his face close to Millie's. I roll my eyes expect Millie to give him no answer because of how tired she is. She nods her head no as she closes her eyes. 

"I'm taking you home Mills," I said lifting her feet up from the ground and carrying her out of the house. I reached my parked car letting Millie lean her body on my car with her head leaning on my chest. I pull out my keys from my pocket unlocking my car and carrying Millie to the front seat. Millie was fast asleep when I placed her down. I pull out my jacket wrapping around her and shutting the door. I hear my name being called from a distance. I look back at Caleb's house seeing Maddie walking wabbly toward me.

"Finn!" Maddie yells again making me run to her with my keys in my hand.

"What's wrong Maddie?" I ask worriedly finally reaching. Maddie wasn't able to stay balanced very long. She quickly wraps her arm around my neck and leans her body on mine. She's definitely drunk. 

"Could you give me a ride home please?" She asks leaning her face close to mine.

"Uh, sure," I said awkwardly bringing her toward my car. I open up the car door of the passenger's seat and place Maddie inside. Maddie quickly lays her body down on the back seats as I shut the door. I turn on the engine of my car and drove off. I hear Maddie moan in pain a couple of times but didn't really do anything about it. She would call my name a couple of times but I wouldn't answer.

"You wanna know a fact about me, Finn?" Maddie asks slowly in a drunk tone.

"Sure," I said as I look at the rear view mirror spotting Maddie still lying on the passenger's seat.

"I have been crushing on you since the first grade ever since you gave me my first kiss," Maddie explains. Her first kiss? I don't remember giving her any kiss in first grade.

"And up until that day, I fell in love with you," How did I not know this? I always say Maddie as a friend nothing else. 

"Everytime you with some girl, I would always be super jealous. I don't know why I can't accept the fact that you'll never love me," She says slowly. She then fell fast asleep. Maddie has a crush on me? How come I never knew this? I made it to Maddie's house. The front porch of her house had its light on. I get out of my car and pull Maddie out of the passenger's seat and pull her to her front door. I doorbell a couple of times waiting for the door to open. A couple of seconds later the door opened showing a girl that looked a lot like Maddie. 

"Oh, come in," She says opening up her door wider. I walk dragging Maddie inside her house. I slowly lay Maddie down on her living room couch.

"Thanks for bringing her here," THe girl says placing a blanket on top of her.

"No problem," I said with my hands in my pocket.

"I'm Mackenzie by the way, her little sister if you were wondering," She says lifting her hand up for me to shake.

"Nice to meet you, I'm Finn," I said taking her hand. She leads to the door.

"So you're the Finn that she's always talking about," Mackenzie says.

"She talks about me?" I ask walking out the door.

"All the time, Thanks again Finn," She says back and shuts the door.

<<>>

(A/N): OHHH MY GOD!! Finn finally knows what Maddie feels about him. But what will happen to Millie?? Thanks for the 2k it really means a lot!! I really didn't think I'd get this much reader. Lots of love to all of you!!

KSHGKSHDGS this is adorable! I wrote ^^^^^ that a year ago. I think innocence losts bday was like three months ago. by the way this chapter was trash. yall thought there would be tea but NOPE.

- Abby