Joe:

I watched as the girl of my dreams worked behind the cash register, taking orders and handing them to the cook in the back room.

I came here every morning for the past three years and yet have never been able to summon the courage to talk to her.

I just didnt know how... I was just another guy with I would say smooth moves. But she made me nervous. I was almlways intimidating to everyone I met with my brown cold eyes and tall figure, but to her I was just another guy.

She was intimidating to me!

Maybe it was the way her brown eyes drilled through my soul when we made eye contact, or maybe the way she moved around the cafe.

I just couldn't do it. And now after three years I had passed her a note. And she told me to wait... To wait after her shift was over.

We would talk.

We would play a game she liked to play.

It was called 'What if I dated you?'.

It sounded like a strange game, but she wanted to play it. And I was excited to play as well.

Bases of the game? Well we had to sit down and act like we were on a date. Tricky part? We had to act like we knew everything about each other, but because we didn't we had to find out what we could by the end if the night.

There she goes. I didn't know much about Afia except her name. And the fact she was a waitress here at the cafe. I was scared. She clocked out and took off her apron to show all her curves which killed me.

She walked to the table with a smirk... I was intimidated by the way she looked at me.. Shoot.

"So, Joe.. Ready to play the game? As a forewarning I already know everything about you" she clarified, intertwining her fingers

Now I felt so small... Intimidated... Terrified. What did she mean...

"Well then, let's play" I breathed, hoping not to show how scared I was

"Yeah okay.. So Joe.. Love... How was your job at the music studio today? Did your manager give you a tough day?" She asked which caused my heart to skip a beat

Joe calm the freak down, anybody can look you up and know you work at a music company...

"It was pretty good actually, my manager had the day off" I replied

She nodded and looked around

"Is your ex and finally leaving you alone?" She asked carefully, sipping a cup of coffee she had brought over

That's when everything around me stopped. I hadn't made Angela public, no one knew we had broken up.

Angela cheated on me so we broke up, some guy named Mark... But the fact that Afia knew Angela was my girlfriend, and that she had been bugging me for the past few days made me realize, Afia was strange...

"Uh.. Y-yeah actually she has. How about your ex?" I asked

She has to have had a boyfriend before.. And I had to act like I knew her so....

"Oh yeah that idiot. He ran away with some whore. Caught them in the act in my very own house" she said with a look of disgust

I sympathized with her. The day I found out about Angela and Mark was when I cane home early from work and found them in the act at my house. I kicked them both out and drank the night away.

"I feel you babe, they don't know when to quit"

She sighed and rolled her eyes

"No kidding."

Suddenly her phone rang and I almost jumped when I saw the caller I'd. It read Mark and had his face on it... Afia was Marks girlfriend. They were both cheaters. We had a connection in one way, both of our ex's were together now...

But they also don't know when to quit.

"Well babe, don't answer that." I said grabbing the phone and pressing ignore

"Well why not? I was about to cuss him out"  she complained

"Because my dear, we could do far worse damage

~*~

This imagine is for PLLFanatic123 who requested this so long ago. I thought of making this really weird and creepy kinda and to me it doesn't make sense but im to lazy to re write it. Bye guys!