This is what I believed would have happened if Astrid never accepted Hiccups apology. Enjoy!

Astrid

"I've been taking you for granted. I have, and I realized that today. I couldn't have done any of this without you, Astrid, no the Dragon Riders or the Edge. You've always been there for me, and I always want to be there for you. I love you, Astrid Hofferson, with everything I have. And I always will." Hiccup said, smiling as he let the words 'I love you' slip out of his mouth.

"Hiccup, you've been taking me for granted for too long, and you apologize now? After a long time! If you want me to forgive you find a way that you can prove to me you're sorry and that you actually love me." I said as I ran down to my hut. I could see Heather following me.

Hiccup

I stood there in shock. What did she just say? Did she just blow me off? I let out all of my feelings for that?! 

"Whelp, now what am I gonna do?" I said as I walked into the clubhouse. Fishlegs patted my back and Snotlout took advantage of the argument.

"So Hiccup, if you blew your chance on Astrid do I get a chance? At least I actually have muscles! SNOTLOUT SNOTLOUT OI OI OI!!!"

I glared at him, and as soon as he saw that glare he ran out of the clubhouse. I laid my head on the table and Fishlegs gave me an idea.

"Take her to a picnic or a special spot. Maybe recreate a special moment or something."

A special moment. A special moment!!! Right there and right then I knew what I was going to do.

"Fishlegs, you're a genius! I have a lot of planning before the sun sets!" I said as I ran down to my hut.

Astrid

I didn't give Hiccup a date to be done by, but I have a feeling it will take a week or two. Meanwhile I was on my bed, crying, while Heather sat next to me.

"Why did you do that? You guys are in love, even better betrothed! Man, I wanted to be your bridesmaid for Thors sake!!" She cried over and over. At about sunset she left to go get some rest, and I laid on my bed, thinking about Hiccup. 

Maybe I should apologize? Maybe I could take it back? No, I can't take it back. I was too harsh! And I know when Hiccup sets his mind in something, he doesn't stop until he finishes.

I sat on my bed until someone threw me in a bag and ran out. I kicked and yelled but nobody came to my rescue. And whoever this person was had a dragon. They flew me out. It was about 10 minutes until whoever took me finally landed. I could feel me being lifted and set gently on the ground. Then the bag opens so I jump out and punch my kidnapper.

Hiccup

"Ow, watch it!" I yell as Astrid punches me. She sees its just me and calms down. "Astrid, its part of the apology."

Astrid gets mad again. "You want to apologize by kidnapping me, flying me to the middle of nowhere and doing nothing!?" she yelled. But then she lightened up as she looked around. "Why are we at Berk?" she asks, looking around.

I put out my arm in front of her. "May we?" I say, and she nods.

Astrid

I feel so bad for punching Hiccup. But at the same time he wants to apologize by kidnapping me!

We are now walking towards the other side of the island, and it feels familiar yet I don't know how. Once we get to the beach on the other side he swigs me off my feet and onto Toothless. We take off into the sky, the Northern Lights shining brighter than the sun.

Then it hits me. I know where we are. I know what he's doing. This is where I first met Toothless. Where me and Hiccup became friends. Where we fell in love about 5 years ago.

"Hiccup, I don't know what to say." I said, tears in my eyes. I knew I meant something to him, I just don't know why all of those hurtful word came out of my mouth.

"Milady, are you crying? I though you never cry." Hiccup says as he lands and wipes my tears.

"Hiccup, I'm sorry about earlier, I didn't mean any of those things I said, you didn't have to do this." I cried. 

Hiccup hugged me. "I did this because you mean a lot to me. I love you."

I smile as I kiss Hiccup, and with that we flew back to the Edge.

When I watched Mi Amore Wing I really wanted there to be more fighting and then more love so I made the story that I dreamed actually happened. Hope you enjoyed!