Your relationship with Horny was going well.
     You're pretty sure that even had you not started dating, you'd be best friends because of how goofy and dorky the two of you really were. Of course, he'd never let things stop at "just friends", especially considering you're the first person to actually understand him and put up with the giant mess that he is.
    He's always been kinda pushy when it comes to the physical stuff, mostly because 1. He can't get enough of you and 2. He's worried that if he doesn't stake his claim to you someone might swoop in and take you from him.
    So you tend to give him slack because of that. And that is what leads to your "first time" which ends up being not too long after you start dating, namely about a few weeks in.
    It all started one day when Archie took you to a diner for some food and pie. While you were there, Archie took off his mask and flirted a bit with the waitress, playfully making you jealous.
    All the while, he teased you under the table, running his fingers across your opening through your panties, chuckling darkly whenever you'd squeak in protest.
    After being teased for awhile, you decided two could play that game and you began palming him through his pants. A low growl sounded beside you.
    "I will punish you later, naughty little minx." He promised, making you shiver at his words.
   The tension continued to rise as the two of you ate your food. Even as you joked and goofed around, you could feel like the very air was charged with sexual tension.
    Finally, after what felt like ages, you and Archie finished your date and left the diner, starting towards home.
    You held hands as you walked down the street when he suddenly pulled you into an alleyway between two large buildings, hiding you in the shadows.
    Your chest heaved with excitement as he pushed you against the nearest wall, sweeping you up into his arms.
    "I can't wait any longer." He said, almost apologetically.
    With that, he pushed up your skirt and moved your underwear to the side so that he could begin rubbing his fingers across your opening.
    A low moan escaped your lips and he growled, "You're so wet! I need you now!"
    So saying, his hands moved to his belt and he unfastened it as fast as his fingers would allow, yanked his pants down, and then his underwear right after, making his erection bob free.
    Your mouth went dry just noticing how big he was but he simply chuckled. "Like what you see?" He pushed you back against the nearest wall. "You're gonna take this here and now, got it, sweetheart?"
    Without waiting for an answer, he thrust forward, filling you completely. He lifted you onto his hips for easier access and began to slowly maneuver you over his cock, rising up, only to, just as slowly, lower yourself onto him.
    All the while, you couldn't help but let moans of pleasure/pain escape your lips. You just wanted him that badly.
   Archie moved his attention to your chest. Pushing your shirt and bra up, he began pinching a nipple as he continued moving you over his cock. A moment later, the same nipple was in his mouth and he was pounding into you faster and more roughly than before.
    Soon your hands were all over him, struggling for something to hold onto as he fucked you senseless. He thrust one more time and came undone.
    Placing his sweaty forehead over yours, he said, "How about we head home for another round?"
    You wholeheartedly agreed.

Ugh this sucks!