In this chapter, Lieutenant Carter Blake and FBI agents Norman and Y/N Jayden meet with Ethan and Maddie Mars' psychologist, Clarence Dupre, in to follow up on the claims made by Grace about her ex-husband's and her best friend's unusual behaviors, which may indicate they are the Origami Killers. The conversation with the psychologist starts off civil enough, with Blake introducing himself and Jayden and Y/N before asking the psychologist about Ethan's and Maddie's mental healths. There are various dialogue prompts for the player to choose from, though they don't directly affect what happens between Blake and Dupré.

As Dupré keeps refusing to tell Blake what he knows of Ethan and Maddie citing patient confidentiality, Blake grows more hostile and threatening. Norman and Y/N can choose to try calming Blake (though again, whatever they say doesn't affect the outcome much here) or joining with Blake to get some answers. Both options must be pursued in order to get both trophies for the chapter.

Eventually, Blake throws Dupré over his desk and proceeds to beat him in an attempt to wring the information out of him. Norman and Y/N can pursue several different courses of action here. They can stand aside and allow Blake to beat the psychologist, tell Blake he has no right to hit the psychologist, threaten to report Blake for his behavior so he is taken off the case, or physically intervene.

No matter what the player chooses to do, Dupré eventually caves and tells Blake, Y/N, and Jayden that Ethan and Maddie are tormented by visions of drowning bodies. He then takes 2 small origami figures out of a drawer in his desk and tells them that they had fallen out of Ethan's and Maddie's pockets a few weeks before during one of their sessions. The chapter ends with Blake ordering the police force to consider Ethan and Maddie Mars 2 suspects.