At the start of the chapter, Ethan and Maddie are sitting at their kitchen table. They are exhausted and thinks about what could have happened to Shaun. They open and read a mysterious letter.

The letter says,

When the parents came home from church,all their children were gone.They searched and called for them,they cried and begged,but it was all to no avail.The children have never been seen again.

Saddened and confused by the letter's message, Ethan and Maddie look in the envelope and finds a ticket to a train station luggage locker. They realize they have no choice but to find out what the locker holds. At the same time, they suspect they may be to blame for Shaun's disappearance and the other killings. They have realized their blackouts and the killings may be linked.

Now the player has the choice on how Ethan and Maddie get to their car. They can leave through the front door and push past the crowd in front of their home, or leave through the back door and sneak around the back alley. Whatever you choose, Ethan and Maddie make it to their car and drives toward Lexington Station.