Ethan and Maddie sit in their motel room, distraught by the outcome of "The Shark." If Madison and Y/M/N are still alive, they arrive with the information from Paco and tries to console them. Maddie and Ethan and Madison and Y/M/N can choose to make love to each other; if they do, Ethan and Maddie will discover that Madison and Y/M/N has been chronicling their encounters and accuses them of lying to and exploiting them, for which they can choose to either forgive or reject them.

Regardless of whether or not Maddie and Ethan and Madison and Y/M/N make love and whether or not they forgive them, Madison and Y/M/N will learn that the police have surrounded the motel and can call Ethan's and Maddie's room to warn them; if Madison and Y/M/N are dead, they will have to spot the police on their own. They must then flee from them to avoid being arrested (again).