Athena has a twin, Bella who she is willing to do anything for. When Bella has to choose between a major audition to forward her acting career or her anniversary date which are on the same date, she picks the audition. Bella begs Athena to take her place on her date with Derrick. Athena gives in and finds herself on a date with Derrick, Bella's boyfriend.

Derrick gets more and more interested in Athena, thinking she's Bella as Bella keeps dodging the dates to further her career because she'd rather become famous without school and keeps convinces Athena to take her place. Then Athena meets someone she's interested in and she has to wrestle her life pretending to be Bella and being herself with this new guy. How will she manage?