It was a sunny day and not a single kid was playing outside. That's because it was the grand opening of Circus Baby's Pizza World. Being the sister location of Freddy's left a bad feeling about it to anyone interested. But once they found out it was by William Afton, their worries were gone.
"Ladies and gentleman! Boys and girls! Welcome to Circus Baby's Pizza World!" He exclaimed at the front of the building. "Usually, entry is $2 but today and today ONLY you get it half off! Even better, you can add 50¢ for EXTRA TOKENS! Scream if you're excited!" Most kids didn't know what he was saying but screamed anyways.
"You can stay until 6:00PM!" Everybody yelled hooray. "Questions will be answered by me and my daughter Elizabeth! Now, get ready for the party of your life!" He yelled as he opened the door. Kids holding money flooded into the building. William stayed outside to chat with the adults for a bit before heading inside.
In the building, the place smelled like fresh pizza. Kids ran around and played, some with their friends and some with the animatronics. It seemed like everyone was happy. But in the corner, Elizabeth sat quietly. She wanted to make sure that if her father's plan failed then she'd be hidden. Only a couple people looked at her. One boy went over to her and sat beside her.
"Who are you?" Elizabeth asked. "My name's John. Yours?" The boy said. "Elizabeth. Why are you over here? Shouldn't you be playing with your friends?" She asked. "John! You're gonna miss Baby's magic trick!" A chubby kid standing beside Baby yelled at John. "I'll be there in a bit, Carlton!" John yelled back. He turned back to Elizabeth. "Aren't you William's daughter?" He asked. "Yeah." Elizabeth replied. "I'll be right back." John said as he got up and went over to his friend Carlton. Meanwhile...
"I've got this whole thing under control! Nothing you can do to stop me now MR. AFTON!" Henry said to himself in the backroom. He started to put on the Funtime Chica suit nobody used. He grabbed the cupcake that went to the suit and put it in between a bunch of random parts on a shelf. He left the backroom and went over to the dining area. He saw a few kids go over to a corner.
     "Elizabeth. This is Carlton and Jessica." John told her. "Hello!" Jessica and Carlton said. Elizabeth looked behind them and saw a Funtime animatronic come towards them. But it was a chicken. "Dad?" She went up to it and asked. "Can you help me find my cupcake? I think I lost it in the back room. Here, follow me!" He/she said. Elizabeth followed Funtime Chica. Secretly, John, Carlton, and Jessica came up behind them. When they got into the room, Funtime Chica stood over Elizabeth. "Time to say goodnight!" He said before stabbing her in the stomach. He had locked the door behind him, so now the other 3 couldn't escape. He stabbed each of them to death before hiding them behind a shelf. He hid himself as well so he could carry out his plan.
     After a few hours of waiting, Henry was able to come out of hiding and dispose of the children's bodies. He took the chubby boy and brought him over to Funtime Freddy. He opened up the chest cavity and squeezed the child inside. He shut it and moved onto the girl. He grabbed her body and put it in Ballora. He took the other boy and put his body into Funtime Foxy. Finally, he grabbed Elizabeth. He started to cradle her in his  arms. "Rock-a-bye bAbY!" He slammed her straight into Circus Baby. The animatronics started twitching and twisting. "My creations are complete!" Henry exclaimed as he walked away and left the building while dropping a round disc...
The next night...
William sat in front of his TV. "How many more reruns will they show of The Immortal and the Restless before the season finale?" He whined. He heard someone knock on the door. He went over to open it and saw the police. "What did I do?" He asked. "It's not what YOU did. Do you know where your daughter is?" The officer asked. It suddenly hit William. His daughter was gone. "WHERE IS SHE?!" HE SCREAMED. "We found her and 3 other children stuffed into your robots. We sincerely feel sorry for your loss, Mr. Afton." To William, everything froze. His daughter was DEAD. "The only evidence we found was this disc with Fazbear Entertainment on it." The cop said. William broke into tears. He lost his only daughter to the monster. Henry ruined everything. Now, he was ready to ruin William. But for a few months, he just sat in his house silently. He ended up letting someone else take the restaurant, he just doesn't know who. But he didn't care. He just wanted his family back...