Requested By~ @sportyartist

Your name was Etsuko Hinata. You had a perfect brown hair and gorgeous ruby red eyes. You was a member of Fairy Tail.

You had a problem. Two boys have confessed to you.

Freed of Fairy Tail.

Rogue of Sabertooth.

Who do you chose? A boy who's from your guild? Or a boy who (is incredibly hot) from another guild?

A boy who had an obsession with Laxus? Or a boy who's a super strong Dragon slayer?

They both had they're pros and cons and you wasn't sure on who to pick.

You was sat at a table, alone, deep in thought when the two boys came up to you.

"Etsuko!" They both said as they slammed one of their hands on the table.

"Eke!" You jumped.

"Who do you choose?" They asked.

"Urgh!" You groaned as you hit your head on the table. Two hot guys had feelings for you. Which made it worst, you felt the same way for them. Suddenly, an idea came to you as you sat up and snapped your fingers. A light bulb literally lit up over your head. "I know, how about this. You both have to give me five reasons why you like me. Come here tomorrow and I will choose." You said as you got up and walked to Mira.

While you weren't look, the two were sending death glares to each other.

"Hello Etsuko, have you chosen who to refuse?" Mirajane asked.

"Nope, but tomorrow, they have to say five reasons why they like me." You explained with a smile. Mira clapped her hands excitedly.

"Can I sit with you? It sounds interesting!" Mira said.

"Sure." You smiled.

The Next Day...

You and Mira sat at the table you was sat at yesterday, waiting for the boys.

"Where are they?" Mira asked.

"Maybe they lost interest?" You shrugged.

"Well, you have some great self-esteem." Mira said sarcastically.

Suddenly, the guild doors opened. They looked and saw Rogue and Freed walk through, sending each other death glares.

They approached you. Freed had a peice of paper in his hand which got you curious.

"Hello boys, are you ready?" Mira asked. They both nodded. "Freed, you go first." Mira smiled. Freed nodded and he looked at his paper.

"I like the fact that you are strong, Etsuko, and you're beautiful, Helpful as well as courageous and fearless on jobs." He said. Your eye twitched. He had to write it on paper? And how would he know you were those things on jobs? You took jobs with Elfman and Lisanna occasionally...

"Oh God! Don't tell me he's a male version of Juvia!" You thought.

"How cute. You're turn Rogue." Mira said. You looked at Rogue and saw his cheeks were a little red.

"What I like about you is that you're kind. I've seen you help little children around town which I thought was sweet. You're also funny and beautiful." He explained.

"He's seen me... Around town?" You thought with an eye twitch.

"Alright boys, put these blindfolds on. I will take one of you boys away while Etsuko will take another one of you outside of the guild." Mira explained. The boys nodded an dput the blindfolds on.

Freed's Ending...

You whispered something to Mira. She nodded and took Rogue somewhere. You took Freed's hand and took him outside the guild. You then took his blindfold off. Freed looked around until he spotted you behind him.

"M-me?" He asked. You smiled and nodded.

"It was really sweet about what you said about me, but how do you know what I'm like on jobs?" You asked.

"W-well... I ask Elfman about it..." He said.

"Why?" You asked.

"B-because I really like you Etsuko!" He said as he turned red. You smiled and then, to stop him from saying anything else, you kissed him on the lips. His eyes went wide, but he soon returned the kiss.

And that's how your day ended with Freed.

Rogue's Ending...

You whispered something to Mira and she nodded. She took Freed somewhere and you took Rogue's hand. You pulled him outside of the guild and took his blindfold off. Rogue turned around and saw you, standing there with a smile.

"Y-you chose me?" He asked. You nodded.

"I like how you described what you thought my personality was like before my looks. That means a lot to me, but by the way, how do you know about me helping little kids?" You asked.

"When Sting pulled me here so he could fight with Natsu, I saw you around town." He explained.

"He really comes all the way here just to pick a fight with Natsu?" You asked, unimpressed. Rogue nodded. "Well he sounds like an idiot. No offence." You said.

"No offense taken." He said. It went to an awkward silence and you decided to break that awkward silence by kissing him on the lips. Rogue was shocked at first but then he went with it.

And that's how your day ended with Rogue.

THE END.

Hello everyone, again, I am sorry its taking me so long to update, I really am and I hope this part is ok because it just came to me. Anyway, I hope you enjoyed this. Bye for now. See you next time :)