Let me get this clear some people hate on the wrong cats. Now it may be opinion based but when StarClan is sending Thistleclaw to the Dark Forest when he hasn't murdered any cats (Scourge doesn't count that was Tigerpaw) and Ashfur being let in even though he tried to kill 3 cats in his clan (one of them his own apprentice) and still gets love I mean what is the deal! Seriously people we are hating on the wrong cats much less loving the wrong cats for the wrong reasons! In my opinion if Jayfeather wasn't blind he wouldn't be as loved as he is today, that would be Hollyleaf. I feel like Jayfeather is only loved because he is blind and he is the one who started the VERY ANNOYING trend of blind medicine cats. Like seriously I hate those! (at least some people do love him for that I don't speak for all) And Millie... I don't hate her, yet I don't love her, I kinda did like her and all people give a crap about is *ohhh but she's the same as Silverstream and neglected her kits* well 1 she isn't why? Because she doesn't blame her father for everything and saying love doesn't hurt anyone, and two Rainflower did the same thing to her kit! And she doesn't get nearly as much hate as she should! Also another hated character is Dovewing, I actually liked Dovewing and Ivypool! I mean yeah I hated Tigerheart and he is the reason Dovewing is hated! And don't tell me *but she's a mary-sue* No she's a nervous reck who could explode at any time. Also Firestar and the Sandstorm couple get WAY to much hate even though the love was ACTUALLY thought out unlike some others *cough* Spottedleaf *cough* So just think about things logically and direct your love and hate to those that deserve it.