There's really not much to say about her other then she's perfect in almost every way, but I'll try. So let's start with her powers, they are as creepy as Jayfeather's powers! 

Imagine there's someone always watching you and hearing everything you say. When the Badgers blocked the river her powers were, even more, OP because she could SEE THEM AND HEAR THEM!!! Seriously creepy. 

Then there was this stupid love triangle between a ShadowClan cat Tigerheart, the ThunderClan cat whose name I don't remember and Dovewing. It really didn't add anything to the story it was there to fill space! 

Then the Erin Hunters can't even decide what eye color she has! It's almost like she has rainbow eyes... Anyway, she is part of a prophecy and is decent from Firestar which is always a sin. The final thing I'm going to talk about is her change of views. First, she's like 'I want to be normal' and once she's normal she's like 'I want to be special' she just can't decide!

I don't think I can lengthen this out anymore so comment down below what cat should be sinned next!