2012

Alberto Del Rio

Dean Ambrose

Triple H

2013

Brock Lesnar

CM Punk

Daniel Bryan

Randy Orton

2014

CM Punk (2)

John Cena

The Undertaker

CM Punk (3)

Rob Van Dam

2015

Dean Ambrose (2)

Finn Balor

Mark Henry

2016

Bray Wyatt

Brock Lesnar (2)

Finn Balor (2)

Rhyno

2017

Aleister Black

Braun Strowman

Drew McIntyre

Neville

2018

Dolph Ziggler

Jeff Hardy

Kane

Rey Mysterio

2019

Big E

Tomasso Ciampa

Johnny Gargano

Bobby Lashley

2020

Big Show

Drew McIntyre (2)

Rusev

2021

Christian

John Cena (2)

Shinsuke Nakamura

Kevin Owens