2010

Batista

John Cena

Rey Mysterio

Triple H

2011

Rey Mysterio (2)

Big Show

John Cena (2)

Daniel Bryan

Dolph Ziggler

Sheamus

2012

Chris Jericho

Daniel Bryan (2)

CM Punk

John Cena (3)

Alberto Del Rio

The Rock

2013

CM Punk (2)

Chris Jericho

Randy Orton (2)

Ryback

Seth Rollins

2014

Bray Wyatt

Finn Balor

Wade Barrett

Roman Reigns

2015

Big Show

Dean Ambrose

John Cena (4)

Randy Orton (3)

Kevin Owens

2016

Dean Ambrose (2)

AJ Styles

Jack Swagger

Finn Balor (2)

Chris Jericho (2)

2017

John Cena (5)

Mark Henry

Neville

Samoa Joe

2018

Adam Cole

AJ Styles (3)

Jeff Hardy

Rey Mysterio (3)

Roman Reigns (2)

2019

Dean Ambrose (3)

Keith Lee

Adam Cole (2)

Kevin Owens (2)

2020

Aleister Black

Adam Cole (3)

Daniel Bryan (3)

Roman Reigns (3)

Drew McIntyre

2021

Bobby Lashley

Daniel Bryan (4)

Karrion Kross

Aleister Black (2)

Daniel Bryan (5)

Adam Cole (4)