Okay so what if Tansypaw Spongepaw  Frecklepaw Willow and Skylar actually come from a long line of great Puddleclan leaders but their great grandmother got exiled.

So the story is:
Their ancestors basically ruled Puddleclan they were expected to be like the ones who came before them. But Creamspot daughter of Lillybreeze and Briskstar never wanted to be leader. However, when her father made her deputy she turned against her father and started killing others. Her father died under mysterious circumstances. She was made leader. Creamstar declared war on Petalclan over stolen prey calling Hailclan to fight with them as defense. Petalclab called Branchclan to fight too dragging every clan in. Puddleclan fell apart some moved out thinking Creamstar was the cause of every. This caused a civil war. Eventually the medicine cat stepped up and exiled her. Moons passed and Creamstar was lost along with the leaders.

drargon
Tanglelight