[This abomination of a drawing belongs to me! So yeah enjoy!]

Aries: Jeff the killer

Capricorn: Sally and Lazari!

Scorpio: Ben Drowned!

Pieces: Laughing jack

Cancer: Slenderman
[Maybe it's best that you just let him have it since he had an exhausting day.]

Leo: Kate the chaser

Libra: Ticci Toby

Aquarius: Hoodie

Virgo: Puppeteer

Gemini: Eyeless jack

Sagittarius: Nina the killer
[Good luck, you need it!]

Taurus: Splendorman
[He was bored]