Who Likes You?

Aries: Shadow

Taurus: Nina the Killer

Gemini: Splendorman

Cancer: Bloody Painter

Leo: Iris

Virgo: Zalgo

Libra: Stripes

Scorpio: Laughing Jill

Sagittarius: Jeff the Killer

Capricorn: Slenderman

Aquarius: The rake (...)

Pisces: Suicide Sadie

(Requested by sunflowerpranker)