Who do you attempt to poison and who succeeds?

Aries: Laughing Jack- Failed

Taurus: Eyeless Jack- Succeed

Gemini: Slenderman- Failed, Lucky for you, he couldn't figure out who did it

Cancer: Zero- Suceed

Leo: Jeff the Killer- Failed

Virgo: Nina the Killer- Failed

Libra: Offenderman - Succeed

Scorpio: Ticci Toby- Fail

Sagittarius: Shadow- Fail

Aquarius: Suicide Saidie- Succeed

Capricorn: Hung Girl/ Iris- Failed

Pisces: Zalgo - Failed