Aries: Jane

Taurus: Slenderman

Gemini: Kate

Cancer: Bloody Painter

Leo: Jeff

Virgo: Splendorman

Libra: Hoodie

Scorpio: Ticci Toby

Sagittarius: clockwork

Capricorn: Laughing Jack

Aquarius: Trenderman

Pisces: Masky

Request by Ilovetoastandikawaii