Boys are on the left and girls are on the right

Aries: Offender/Candy Pop
OOF 😆 I feel bad for you who got Offender 😢

Taurus: Toby/Lazari

Gemini: Hoodie/Nurse Ann

Cancer: LJ/Suicide Sadie

Leo: Ben/Judge angel

Virgo: Jeff/Iris the storyteller

Libra: puppeteer/Zero

Scorpio: EJ/Four eyed Jessy

Sagittarius: Slendy/Sketcher

Capricorn: Dr. smiley/Clockwork

Aquarius: Homicidal Liu/Jane

Pisces: Masky/Killing Kate

Request by @UnicornLoverF1