Who watches you kidnap a penguin from the zoo?

Capricorn- Hoodie

Aquarius- Jane the Everlasting

Pisces- Slenderman

Aries- Sally

Taurus- Zalgo

Gemini- Fran Bow(Not a creepypasta, but she was there for whatever reason)

Cancer- Homicidal Liu

Leo- Kagekao

Virgo- Eyeless Jack

Libra- Laughing Jack

Scorpio- Candy Pop

Sagittarius- Grinny Cat(He accidentally got put in a cage)