(sorry it's a little late)

Who's your valentine?

Capricorn- Slenderman

Aquarius- Kate the Chaser

Pisces- Jane the Everlasting

Aries- Smile Dog

Taurus- BEN Drowned

Gemini- Masky

Cancer- Laughing Jack

Leo-  Kagekao

Virgo- Jeff the Killer

Libra- Dark Link

Scorpio- Hoodie

Sagittarius- Puppeteer