Aries - Judge Angels gives you a Battle Axe.

Taurus - Lost Silver gives you a Pokémon.

Gemini - Kagekao gives you Shurikens.

Cancer - Sally gives you a Dagger.

Leo - Jane Everlasting gives you a Sword.

Virgo - Clockwork gives you a Lance.

Libra - Puppeteer gives you a Crossbow.

Scorpio - Zalgo gives you a Scythe.

Sagittarius - Eyeless Jack gives you a Hatchet.

Capricorn - Sonic.exe gives you a Gun.

Aquarius - Dark Link gives you a Rocket Launcher.

Pisces - Slenderman gives you a Scepter.