~Who kisses you under the mistletoe~

Aries: Hoodie

Taurus: Eyeless Jack

Gemini: BEN Drowned

Cancer: The Bloody Painter

Leo: Jeff The Killer

Virgo: Slenderman (I....wha?...how?!)

Libra: Candy Pop

Scorpio: Masky

Sagittarius: The Puppeter

Capricorn: Dark Link

Aquarius: Laughing Jack

Pisces: Ticci Toby