Who kissed you under a mistletoe -

Aries - BEN Drowned

Taurus - Jeff The Killer

Gemini - Hoodie

Cancer - Homicidal Liu

Leo - Puppeteer

Virgo - Eyeless Jack

Libra - Laughing Jack

Scorpio - Bloody Painter

Sagittarius - Dr. Smiley

Capricorn - Slenderman

Aquarius - Ticci Toby

Pisces - Dark Link