Broke your heart -

Aries - Hoodie

Taurus - Herobrine

Gemini - Sally

Cancer - BEN Drowned

Leo - Laughing Jack

Virgo - Dark Link

Libra - Smile Dog

Scorpio - Homicidal Liu

Sagittarius - Puppeteer

Capricorn - Nurse Ann

Aquarius - Slenderman

Pisces - Nightmare Ally